| aleuzzi |
05-06-2015 08:50 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by seekerj
(Post 1165722)
Hmmm, Christine doesn't agree. From Contemporary Keyboard, 10/1980:
"She isn't a great player, but what she plays you can elaborate on. Still, I think she should play onstage. She's getting better all the time, and if she would play piano on one song, it'd be ****in' great! Then she'd be known as a musician as well as just a singer."
http://bla.fleetwoodmac.net/index.ph...x_v2&id=11&c=2
And, she sounded just fine playing the acoustic guitar rhythm parts on Go Your Own Way on that Rumours rehearsal tape where eventually Lindsey gives the guitar to Ray. I still wonder why he did that, if maybe his motive wasn't entirely musical.
The Leather And Lace demo with her plucking the guitar was fine, too. Her rhythm guitar on her version of Free Fallin' wasn't terrible, either.
I mean, yeah, she doesn't have the abilities that others with more experience have, but an amateur at best??
She herself has said that she isn't a musician. She uses the instruments for what she needs them for in order to write songs. So if she isn't putting herself in that category, what are you arguing with???? Why are you throwing her into that category and then saying she doesn't belong there??!!!!
|
Honestly, the term for Stevie's abilities on guitar and keyboards IS amateur. It's not a slight or dismissal of her abilities as a musician (she is a unique songwriter and equally distinctive singer who can also harmonize like no other). While it is true that she can manage to work her way around a keyboard or guitar to get the right chords for structuring songs, she can't really play either of these instruments beyond base-level proficiency, which is the definition of an amateur.
Moreover, she has a VERY difficult time singing and playing piano at the same time. Whenever she steps towards a piano to accompany herself I want to yell out, Noooooo, don't do it! Her performances of Rhiannon at the piano are embarrassing because she can't get the coordination right to both sing and play at the same time.
All this aside, she has gone far, very far, with what she does know. Her amateur instrumental skills have actually helped her find inventive ways to maneuver for chords, and thus have contributed to her unusual harmonic and melodic styles.
But Christine's 1979 interview is an example of Christine either being magnanimous and/or passive aggressive in a back-handed complement kind of way. The assessment of Stevie's abilities there seems indulgent, a tad condescending, which is how the entire band has made her feel at one time or another. I can't say I really blame them: Stevie has had plenty of time and opportunity to learn an instrument more fluently.
|