The Ledge

The Ledge (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/index.php)
-   Rumours (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   STEVIE NICKS IS GOING HER OWN WAY - Sunday Express Oct. 18, 2009 (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/showthread.php?t=41912)

CADreaming 10-18-2009 07:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nico (Post 848339)
Hmmm...nah, I think she kinda digs him for real. And he appears to care less unfortunately.:shrug:

(But look, if you asked me...idratherhavelindseybuckingham"stillinlove"withmethanthatfuglycreatureanyday,eventhoughjoewalshisagreatmusicianandihaveallhisalbums)


:lol::lol::lol::lol:

That's all I'm sayin'. Plus, I think Walsh is a pig. God help her if she really feels that way.

APerfectLie 10-18-2009 08:11 PM

I can honestly see Fleetwood Mac doing another album, but I don't see them touring for another 7-8 years. I've learned not to hold my breath when it comes to what Stevie says. I mean hell, she has been saying she is going to release a book in a "few years" for the past 25 years! And in an interview earlier this year she said after she is done with whatever Fleetwood Mac is doing, she is going to make a new solo record because she feels she needs too. But the main reason I just don't see her dedicating the next 7-8 years solely to Fleetwood Mac is because she cannot stand Lindsey. In the 60 minutes interview they did a few months back, when asked about Lindsey she said, "Well he's not my best friend, and he never will be." So you can see he is already getting on her nerves like usual. I think if Fleetwood Mac decide to do a new album, she will tour for the record, but I think after that she will want to go back and do another solo record before working on another FM album. The last time Stevie did 2 FM albums with nothing solo in between was during Rumours and Tusk. And since Christine isn't around, I really don't see Stevie leaving her solo career alone so she can go spend the next 8 years dancing across the stages of the world with Fleetwood Mac. If anything, she will take a break from both her solo work and FM.

LikeAWillow 10-18-2009 08:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nico (Post 848331)
I think she says that "love of your life" crap so Lindsey doesn't think she's still pining over his happily-married ass. She'd be singing a different tune if it were a different circumstance, I guarantee- that is, she'd either be bitching about his "darkness" or saying how amazing he was. Either/or or just simultaneously, but Joe Walsh would be a mere speck.

Bingo. For all her talk of his undying love for her, his life and marriage seem perfectly stable, while her bitterness grows each year. How many times have we heard that it was always a competition between them? She needs something (or someone) to show us that as happy as he looks, she's still winning.

michelej1 10-18-2009 08:17 PM

Stevie does not like to be idle. So, she and FM may work together for 7-8 more years, but it won't be consistently. If there is any down time, you can bet that she will squeeze a solo tour in.

But as for her ever doing another solo album? Maybe not. I'm positive there will be more solo tours from her though. Michele

mgikallaroundme 10-18-2009 08:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jbrownsjr (Post 848298)
I honestly now really understand why Christine left. It's because you had to be drunk and all coked up to deal with these people. She probably sobered up and couldn't deal with them. They sound like morons in these interviews and I get annoyed just reading them. Imagine touring a whole year listening to these two...

We loved Say You Will, we hate Say You Will, I'm not touring ever again without Christine, I'll tour without Christine. We got along really well during SYW, all we did was fight during SYW. Sheryl Crow is joining the band, Sheryl Crow isn't joining the band. We have eight more years in us, I don't have enough time to eat a meal and I'm exhausted.

:lol: ROTFLMFAOPIMP!!!!



Quote:

Bottom line... WE NEED YOUR MONEY!!
:nod:

StreetAngel86 10-18-2009 09:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848198)
“I’m a performer and an entertainer, that’s what I live for. I would be dancing on tables in bars if I wasn’t in Fleetwood Mac, doing small shows all over the world, driving my van.”

:lol:

Stevie is my favorite person to read interviews from EVER!
she comes up with the craziest one liners and statements like this :laugh:

that SYW stuff is crap
i think she only sees the negative aspects and not the fun side of it
like her only memories of making it are fighting with lindsey over the tracklisting and the double album and the END of the tour
well what about all the inbetween stuff
there were lotsa happy Stevie smiles on that tour :P

Quote:

Originally Posted by LikeAWillow (Post 848347)
Bingo. For all her talk of his undying love for her, his life and marriage seem perfectly stable, while her bitterness grows each year. How many times have we heard that it was always a competition between them? She needs something (or someone) to show us that as happy as he looks, she's still winning.

i think Stevie is maybe kinda jealous he has that [seemingly] stable life [wife.kids etc] and she doesnt. that competition comment is soooooo true. if i cant have lindsey, well no1 can have lindsey and i certainly aint gonna let him be happy without me. you NEEEEEEEEED me lindsey :p
i think she goes around saying she hates him and will never be friends with him to hide her real feelings. she cant exactly go around saying she still loves him and wishes she was his wife and blah blah blah Lindsey would prob holla a "Sucked in baby, you left ME" at her OR Mrs Buck would be NOT impressed with Mama and Lindsey would get it all and it would come back on Stevie :lol:

jmn3 10-18-2009 09:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jbrownsjr (Post 848298)
I honestly now really understand why Christine left. It's because you had to be drunk and all coked up to deal with these people. She probably sobered up and couldn't deal with them. They sound like morons in these interviews and I get annoyed just reading them. Imagine touring a whole year listening to these two...

We loved Say You Will, we hate Say You Will, I'm not touring ever again without Christine, I'll tour without Christine. We got along really well during SYW, all we did was fight during SYW. Sheryl Crow is joining the band, Sheryl Crow isn't joining the band. We have eight more years in us, I don't have enough time to eat a meal and I'm exhausted.

Bottom line... WE NEED YOUR MONEY!!

lol....great assessment, I've had the same thought myself. I could just imagine Chris sitting there, listening to this crap, giving a slight glance in John's direction while rolling her eyes about these two. The older they get, Lindsey takes 500 words to get across one point and Stevie is basically just bitchy all the time. It would be refreshing to just hear:

LB: You know, she's a bitch, I don't really even like her, but we need each other to be successful (i.e. make money).
SN: Yeah, he's a real asshole, he's been mean to me forever, but we need each other to be successful (i.e. make money).

CADreaming 10-18-2009 09:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jmn3 (Post 848368)
lol....great assessment, I've had the same thought myself. I could just imagine Chris sitting there, listening to this crap, giving a slight glance in John's direction while rolling her eyes about these two. The older they get, Lindsey takes 500 words to get across one point and Stevie is basically just bitchy all the time. It would be refreshing to just hear:

LB: You know, she's a bitch, I don't really even like her, but we need each other to be successful (i.e. make money).
SN: Yeah, he's a real asshole, he's been mean to me forever, but we need each other to be successful (i.e. make money).

I agree with you to an extent. But, they don't need each other to be successful.

jmn3 10-18-2009 09:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CADreaming (Post 848369)
I agree with you to an extent. But, they don't need each other to be successful.

Agreed, but look at what I put in parenthesis, that's what they need each other for. I was being somewhat facetious in reference to what they seemingly equate success with (money). Lindsey and Stevie can do all the solo albums and tours that they want, but in 2009 and beyond, the REAL money is in Fleetwood Mac and they each know it.

Kayt1234 10-18-2009 09:56 PM

Ugh, I sometimes wish Stevie would stop, take a breath and THINK about how she words things. I honestly don't think she means to be condescening or arrogant or ANYTHING...I think she really doesn't word her thoughts correctly (which is so ironic seeing what a great writer is). I think when she said that about Lindsey, I really believe that she meant it positively. That a wonderful thing ABOUT him was how he loved her.

As for the whole Joe Walsh thing *rolls eyes*. I think we've all been in situations where we look back on something that wasn't so wonderful but remembered the good things. I do it all the time with certain ex-boyfriends. Then, you remember. I obviously know nothing about any of the private moments between Stevie and Joe but I do know that he treated her terribly. Some of the things he said about her, the way he constantly abandoned her...everything. And yes, we can say he was on drugs and was messed up- She was messed up herself. Still, the fact is he did treat her that way and it really does break my heart that she holds him on that pedestal.

and maybe it's just me but...I love Say You Will. I really do!

daniellaaarisen 10-18-2009 09:57 PM

But if it was ALL hate, this band would've been over quite long ago.

michelej1 10-18-2009 10:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kayt1234 (Post 848373)
Ugh, I sometimes wish Stevie would stop, take a breath and THINK about how she words things. I honestly don't think she means to be condescening or arrogant or ANYTHING...I think she really doesn't word her thoughts correctly (which is so ironic seeing what a great writer is). I think when she said that about Lindsey, I really believe that she meant it positively. That a wonderful thing ABOUT him was how he loved her.

I think she meant it that way and that the message is not only that Lindsey loved her that much, but that she never loved him as much in return. I think that's the impression that she wants to leave, although I don't think it's a reflection of what she really feels.

And it's not that this behavior is one-sided on her part. Lindsey has done it too. I mean, he was the one saying that Stevie and Mick were in cahoots to get him to stand closer to her on stage and play up their star crossed love and -- true or not -- I think he would only say that to be petty. And I know I think he was doing a Rolling Stone interview in the eighties and Stevie called him on the phone and he said something to the writer about her longing for his approval. I mean, I think she DOES want his approval. She is the one who said that she hoped he was finally just a little bit proud of her when she did the TISL album. So, I don't think what he said was untrue, but I do think he said it to be mean.

So, he says things to needle her just the same way she does it to him. The only difference is, Lindsey's behavior in that regard, his propensity to take jabs at her through the media, has improved and become a lot less frequent over the years. Hers hasn't. I'm not saying he's not being just as childish with her in private as she is, but he's not doing it overtly in public as much as she is.

Michele

Amlyn 10-18-2009 10:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848198)
As their cocaine addiction spiralled out of control in the early Eighties, though, Walsh reluctantly left her for both of their sakes. Now she muses: “Maybe the people you can live best with aren’t the great love of your life; the men you love deeply, the calmer, more loving, more solid people but who you weren’t super passionately crazy in love with. The ones to marry aren’t the ones as crazy as you are.”

Ok, help me out. What point is she trying to get across with this quote? Is she talking about Joe or Lindsey here? Both perhaps? Not that I'm surprised but the whole thing seems to be a contradiction within itself. Anyone care to try to intepret this Steviespeak?

I also wonder if the author just pulled the "Joe is the great love of my life" stuff from older interviews just to try to tie it to this quote which appears to be more recent given the phrasing.

daniellaaarisen 10-18-2009 10:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Amlyn (Post 848389)

I also wonder if the author just pulled the "Joe is the great love of my life" stuff from older interviews just to try to tie it to this quote which appears to be more recent given the phrasing.

I hope so. Whatever portion of my faith in her that was lost because of this interview will be partially restored.

Amlyn 10-18-2009 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by daniellaaarisen (Post 848391)
I hope so. Whatever portion of my faith in her that was lost because of this interview will be partially restored.

Well on the upside, to my knowledge, we have only a few articles with this reference.

michelej1 10-18-2009 11:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Amlyn (Post 848389)
Ok, help me out. What point is she trying to get across with this quote? Is she talking about Joe or Lindsey here? Both perhaps? Not that I'm surprised but the whole thing seems to be a contradiction within itself. Anyone care to try to intepret this Steviespeak?

I don't think she's talking about Joe or Lindsey there. She says things were always volatile with Lindsey and they were with Joe too. Both of these men went on to forge long lasting relationships, but with women who were different from them and different from Stevie. I think Stevie is saying maybe that would have been the key for her as well.

So, I think she's talking about Carl the nebbish accountant who really loved her, but whom she just wasn't that into. Maybe she realizes that that's who could have brought her the most happiness. Not the heart-soaring highs and lows, rage and desire, but the day in and day out contentment. The nurturing, "normal" family life. He could have steadied out her rock star urges and with him and his horn-rimmed glasses she could have found peace and balance. But it was never to be.

Michele

Amlyn 10-18-2009 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by michelej1 (Post 848402)
I don't think she's talking about Joe or Lindsey there. She says things were always volatile with Lindsey and they were with Joe too. Both of these men went on to forge long lasting relationships, but with women who were different from them and different from Stevie. I think Stevie is saying maybe that would have been the key for her as well.

So, I think she's talking about Carl the nebbish accountant who really loved her, but whom she just wasn't that into. Maybe she realizes that that's who could have brought her the most happiness. Not the heart-soaring highs and lows, rage and desire, but the day in and day out contentment. The nurturing, "normal" family life. He could have steadied out her rock star urges and with him and his horn-rimmed glasses she could have found peace and balance. But it was never to be.

Michele


Well, in some ways that's a relief. Otherwise the only songs we'd ever have had from her would have been about 1099s and feeling neglected during tax season.

But seriously, now that you put the comment into that context for me, I can see how it is relevant.

Nikolaj 10-19-2009 02:09 AM

" I didn't like the songs" is the quote that's staying with me, some 8 hours after having read the article. She didn't say "I didn't like my songs"- I have a feeling she did like her songs, 'Silver Girl' and all. Yet, she didn't come out and say "I didn't like Lindsey's songs on SYW" but I think that may be closer to the truth.
Regarding some of the comments here about 'Tusk'- it was as early as 1986 when Stevie said that she did like the album. The famous Australian interview- with Molly somebody (a guy) and she said something like "I liked that album a lot and even liked Lindsey's songs on it a lot, which is what most of the criticism was about"-- she also commented she thought it was an album that could take a long time for people to 'get' but that eventually, in their quiet, alone, time, there'd be a lot of people who would really appreciate 'Tusk' and she was glad they made the album. Stevie then sang a smidge of 'Walk A Thin Line'- one song of LB's that I totally love (there are others) and it would be heaven to hear her do the song completely.

michelej1 10-19-2009 02:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nikolaj (Post 848425)
" I didn't like the songs" is the quote that's staying with me, some 8 hours after having read the article. She didn't say "I didn't like my songs"- I have a feeling she did like her songs, 'Silver Girl' and all. Yet, she didn't come out and say "I didn't like Lindsey's songs on SYW" but I think that may be closer to the truth.
Regarding some of the comments here about 'Tusk'- it was as early as 1986 when Stevie said that she did like the album. The famous Australian interview- with Molly somebody (a guy) and she said something like "I liked that album a lot and even liked Lindsey's songs on it a lot, which is what most of the criticism was about"-- she also commented she thought it was an album that could take a long time for people to 'get' but that eventually, in their quiet, alone, time, there'd be a lot of people who would really appreciate 'Tusk' and she was glad they made the album. Stevie then sang a smidge of 'Walk A Thin Line'- one song of LB's that I totally love (there are others) and it would be heaven to hear her do the song completely.

I think Stevie liked her songs, but think that someone else could have done a better job with them. I mean, we all love Thrown Down, but I think she thinks it could have been better. Then, there are songs like Smile at You where many people say her demos were better. She probably thinks they were too.

I think she probably was unhappy with the album all along. I wouldn't say she looks proud as punch in Destiny Rules. In fact, I'd say that she probably heard what he did with her old songs, while she was on tour, didn't like it and that's why she wrote 4 new songs at breakneck speed. But even though Lindsey bears the brunt of all of her unhappiness with SYW, probably he's only really responsible for a part of it.

I do remember Stevie saying when Tusk came out that she liked Walk a Thin Line, when asked to name one of Lindsey's songs that she liked on the album. Then of course we have the reference in the Mirror, Mirror lyrics. I really like that. Michele

BellaDonna93 10-19-2009 03:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RockALittle250 (Post 848310)
With reports that Fleetwood Mac are planning a new record in January of 2010, touring for another 7 to 8 years, and hopefully putting out another record in between that, I am more and more convinced that Stevie is doing exactly what Gwen Stefani is doing, and that is, leaving her solo career behind.

I hope this is Stevie speaking the truth about Fleetwood Mac touring 7-8 years more and do more albums:blob2: :blob1:BUT I sooooo hope this isn't the end of her solo career!!!! :( :(

CADreaming 10-19-2009 07:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by michelej1 (Post 848402)

So, I think she's talking about Carl the nebbish accountant who really loved her, but whom she just wasn't that into. Maybe she realizes that that's who could have brought her the most happiness. Not the heart-soaring highs and lows, rage and desire, but the day in and day out contentment. The nurturing, "normal" family life. He could have steadied out her rock star urges and with him and his horn-rimmed glasses she could have found peace and balance. But it was never to be.

Michele


:laugh::laugh: Alas, Destiny does Rule.


Quote:

Originally Posted by michelej1 (Post 848428)
I think Stevie liked her songs, but think that someone else could have done a better job with them. I mean, we all love Thrown Down, but I think she thinks it could have been better. Then, there are songs like Smile at You where many people say her demos were better. She probably thinks they were too.

I think she probably was unhappy with the album all along. I wouldn't say she looks proud as punch in Destiny Rules. In fact, I'd say that she probably heard what he did with her old songs, while she was on tour, didn't like it and that's why she wrote 4 new songs at breakneck speed. But even though Lindsey bears the brunt of all of her unhappiness with SYW, probably he's only really responsible for a part of it.

Since when does she think someone else could have done a better job with her songs? This part just baffles me. I mean, Petty says he thinks LB is her best producer...she was falling all over herself wanting LB to work with her again...so why does she feel this way about the SYW songs? I am having a hard time justifying this line of thinking. Are we saying that Lindsey's "lost his touch" - or just with her songs?

Am I the only person who likes SYW?? :lol:

Bryan 10-19-2009 07:43 AM

Hmm,SYW. I loved it when it was out,for the time it was out and that was that. I can't even listen to it now,it's just a very odd sounding record.:confused:
So I can see where she's coming from with that comment..I suppose.

TrueFaith77 10-19-2009 08:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CADreaming (Post 848450)
:laugh::laugh: Alas, Destiny does Rule.




Since when does she think someone else could have done a better job with her songs? This part just baffles me. I mean, Petty says he thinks LB is her best producer...she was falling all over herself wanting LB to work with her again...so why does she feel this way about the SYW songs? I am having a hard time justifying this line of thinking. Are we saying that Lindsey's "lost his touch" - or just with her songs?

Stevie's solo career is mired in bad, cheesy production. In the past, Lindsey had mastered the pop form that Stevie aped in the 80s albums. Now, Lindsey's approach has evolved. I think that's a good thing (even if it has evolved in ways that I don't personally prefer). As SYW proves, that evolution in sound also benefits Stevie's tracks. Illume, EFO, DR, TD, SYW, RTTG are thrilling productions (even if they all start the same :laugh:) -- while the much-maligned GB, SAY, and Silver Girl could hardly have been better. GB is a beautiful closer to the album; its production serves the album -- and I admire the metronome! Also, SAY really isn't much of a song, though its dramatic situation is utterly compelling, but Lindsey turns it into a sonic adventure -- it's as great as it could be, really. I, too, would love to hear that song performed live, more "unleashed" -- but as a studio track, this is what they do. As a solo recording artist, she's never more raw, just cheesier. As for Silver Girl -- the only good thing about that is FM's participation (bye bye flute) and its contextualization on the album: SAY, RTTG, and Silver Girl forming a kind of trilogy of Stevie's maturation at the album's midpoint.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CADreaming (Post 848450)
Am I the only person who likes SYW?? :lol:

I love SYW! I should start a poll...

HejiraNYC 10-19-2009 09:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TrueFaith77 (Post 848457)
Stevie's solo career is mired in bad, cheesy production. In the past, Lindsey had mastered the pop form that Stevie aped in the 80s albums.

I don't know how you can say something like that without looking at all pop music in context. Face it: the 1980's was cheesy (especially 1984-onward). And in that vein, Rock a Little was an artifact of its time, whereas Wild Heart and Bella Donna were less so. And I don't know how you could possibly state that Stevie aped Lindsey when she was the first FM member to embrace that modern 80's sound in 1985. If anything, Lindsey was the one who aped Stevie with TITN in 1987. And TOSTM doesn't sound a thing like TITN- if anything in some ways it just picked up where RAL left off.

Quote:

Now, Lindsey's approach has evolved. I think that's a good thing (even if it has evolved in ways that I don't personally prefer). As SYW proves, that evolution in sound also benefits Stevie's tracks.
Yes, Lindsey's approach has evolved... but in his case, I don't think evolution is necessarily a good thing. He has been on a musical journey, surely. But I think his style has become a bit too heavy-handed and forced. What I loved about albums like Rumours and Tusk was that they were rough yet effortlessly polished at the same time. And even when a song was very heavily produced, e.g., "Sara" or "You Make Loving Fun," there was something very warm and organic about it. In recent efforts, it seems like Lindsey was just digging through his electronic bag of tricks and trying to use every effect he can throw at a song. For me, the results are not "cutting edge" as much as they are cold and mechanical. Rather than complementing the songs, his production tends to overpower the songs. Yes, one could argue that perhaps the material on an album like SYW was so weak that it needed a lot of heavy-handed production. But on songs like "Smile at You," which was pretty great to begin with, I think he could have dialed back the vocoders and Pro Tools a notch and employed a simpler, sparser sonic field. Not to say that it was all bad- I think the production on "Destiny Rules" was perfect, as well as "Thrown Down." But two or three good songs out of ten (Stevie) songs is not a good batting average.

Black_Moon 10-19-2009 10:29 AM

I think the material on Say You Will is a lot better than what most people are giving it credit for. Sure, I disagree with some of the production approaches -- particularly on the likes of Smile at You and Silver Girl (the latter of which I hate anyway, but the production makes it worse).

I think Stevie had some amazing songs on the album though, the likes of Illume, Running Through The Garden, Destiny Rules, Thrown Down and Everybody Finds Out (which I also find slightly over-produced but still love).

JazmenFlowers 10-19-2009 10:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848463)
But on songs like "Smile at You," which was pretty great to begin with, I think he could have dialed back the vocoders and Pro Tools a notch and employed a simpler, sparser sonic field. Not to say that it was all bad- I think the production on "Destiny Rules" was perfect, as well as "Thrown Down." But two or three good songs out of ten (Stevie) songs is not a good batting average.

agreed!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Black_Moon (Post 848469)
I think the material on Say You Will is a lot better than what most people are giving it credit for. Sure, I disagree with some of the production approaches -- particularly on the likes of Smile at You and Silver Girl (the latter of which I hate anyway, but the production makes it worse).

I think Stevie had some amazing songs on the album though, the likes of Illume, Running Through The Garden, Destiny Rules, Thrown Down and Everybody Finds Out (which I also find slightly over-produced but still love).

I love Silver Girl so much and it always kills me that so many hate it. oh well. otherwise, I totally agree with what you're saying.

with respect to the article, I decided a long time ago to read Stevie's interviews very lightly and not put too much stock into them. she seems to say things depending on her mood - you can't ever trust what she predicts will happen and her feelings totally change on everything from marriage to kids to songs to men, etc. it is what it is. you gotta kinda take each interview separate and apart. it sucks, but being that Stevie has never really lived in the real world (despite what she'd have us believe) she's totally out of touch and can't hear how stupid some of her comments are. at least she does give us fabulous zingers in each and every one!

TrueFaith77 10-19-2009 10:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848463)
I don't know how you can say something like that without looking at all pop music in context. Face it: the 1980's was cheesy (especially 1984-onward). And in that vein, Rock a Little was an artifact of its time, whereas Wild Heart and Bella Donna were less so.

I could name 100s of non-cheesy 80s albums; I just don't know if Stevie heard any of them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848463)
And I don't know how you could possibly state that Stevie aped Lindsey when she was the first FM member to embrace that modern 80's sound in 1985. If anything, Lindsey was the one who aped Stevie with TITN in 1987. And TOSTM doesn't sound a thing like TITN- if anything in some ways it just picked up where RAL left off.

Yes, Stevie incorporated new technology for a more commercial sound; I just think that her approach to songcraft was meant to ape Lindsey's pop sheen on Rumours. THE RESULT: bland. IF Lindsey brought in 80s accoutrement for TITN in order to capitalize on expectations of Stevie's sound, then I would say: he did it better for her than anyone else had.

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848463)
Yes, Lindsey's approach has evolved... but in his case, I don't think evolution is necessarily a good thing. He has been on a musical journey, surely. But I think his style has become a bit too heavy-handed and forced. What I loved about albums like Rumours and Tusk was that they were rough yet effortlessly polished at the same time. And even when a song was very heavily produced, e.g., "Sara" or "You Make Loving Fun," there was something very warm and organic about it. In recent efforts, it seems like Lindsey was just digging through his electronic bag of tricks and trying to use every effect he can throw at a song. For me, the results are not "cutting edge" as much as they are cold and mechanical. Rather than complementing the songs, his production tends to overpower the songs. Yes, one could argue that perhaps the material on an album like SYW was so weak that it needed a lot of heavy-handed production. But on songs like "Smile at You," which was pretty great to begin with, I think he could have dialed back the vocoders and Pro Tools a notch and employed a simpler, sparser sonic field. Not to say that it was all bad- I think the production on "Destiny Rules" was perfect, as well as "Thrown Down." But two or three good songs out of ten (Stevie) songs is not a good batting average.

I agree that Lindsey has lost his warmth in the Rumours sense and in the Tusk sense, too, -- there it's an experimental warmth! That was his peak, I agree, but his new approach is fascinating and impactful and beautiful (to me). And on Stevie's songs, all of which are good-to-great on SYW, I feel he makes them even greater; or, rather, allows them to achieve their full potential in ways she NEVER has as a solo artist.

JazmenFlowers 10-19-2009 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TrueFaith77 (Post 848472)
And on Stevie's songs, all of which are good-to-great on SYW, I feel he makes them even greater; or, rather, allows them to achieve their full potential in ways she NEVER has as a solo artist.

wow, really? really? idk.

TrueFaith77 10-19-2009 11:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JazmenFlowers (Post 848474)
wow, really? really? idk.

Well, with EO17 being the exception...

HejiraNYC 10-19-2009 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TrueFaith77 (Post 848472)
And on Stevie's songs, all of which are good-to-great on SYW, I feel he makes them even greater; or, rather, allows them to achieve their full potential in ways she NEVER has as a solo artist.

I have to disagree vehemently! I happen to think John Shanks, based on his work on TISL, was by far Stevie's best producer. Yes, his production style is also very heavy, but it is also very sympathetic to the material. Rather than having weird sound effects and gizmos popping up in random places, Shanks created an entirely otherworldly soundscape that was the perfect accompaniment to Stevie's otherworldly vocals and imagery. I think "Planets of the Universe" is a masterpiece in Shanks' hands, especially when you consider that skeletal little piano demo that Stevie recorded in waltz time; I don't think Lindsey would have even begun to know what to do with it. And I believe reading somewhere that "Fall From Grace" had been attempted as a Fleetwood Mac song, but neither Lindsey nor Sheryl were able to do anything with it. I'm not denying that Lindsey has been able to turn coal into diamonds, e.g., "Dreams," but I think his recent work on Stevie's songs were more about Lindsey putting his signature on her songs than about realizing the full potential of the song.

It would be interesting to see what a non-Lindsey-produced FM album would sound like, especially if it is produced by a younger producer who grew up listening to Rumours. It could either be disgustingly, superficially retro or it could be a deconstructed, potent distillation of everything we love about FM.

michelej1 10-19-2009 11:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CADreaming (Post 848450)
Since when does she think someone else could have done a better job with her songs? This part just baffles me. I mean, Petty says he thinks LB is her best producer...she was falling all over herself wanting LB to work with her again...so why does she feel this way about the SYW songs? I am having a hard time justifying this line of thinking. Are we saying that Lindsey's "lost his touch" - or just with her songs?

Am I the only person who likes SYW?? :lol:

I made a mistake and left off an "s". I meant she thinks, not I think. I was just talking about Stevie's perception. I don't think that some other producer could have done a better job with her songs. I think they all sound great, except for Silver Girl and RTTG and I only really blame the production on RTTG. I think RTTG could have been better, tighter and differentiated. As it is, it's just one monotonous thing.

I think LB did as good of a job on Silver Girl as was possible. In fact, if I think an outside producer was needed on the album, I'd get one to lend an objective ear to Lindsey's songs, not Stevie's.

I am thrilled with the SYW album and love it as a whole, even when it fails in places.

Michele

TrueFaith77 10-19-2009 11:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848477)
I have to disagree vehemently! I happen to think John Shanks, based on his work on TISL, was by far Stevie's best producer. Yes, his production style is also very heavy, but it is also very sympathetic to the material. Rather than having weird sound effects and gizmos popping up in random places, Shanks created an entirely otherworldly soundscape that was the perfect accompaniment to Stevie's otherworldly vocals and imagery. I think "Planets of the Universe" is a masterpiece in Shanks' hands, especially when you consider that skeletal little piano demo that Stevie recorded in waltz time; I don't think Lindsey would have even begun to know what to do with it. And I believe reading somewhere that "Fall From Grace" had been attempted as a Fleetwood Mac song, but neither Lindsey nor Sheryl were able to do anything with it. I'm not denying that Lindsey has been able to turn coal into diamonds, e.g., "Dreams," but I think his recent work on Stevie's songs were more about Lindsey putting his signature on her songs than about realizing the full potential of the song.

I think TISL is, for the most part, hideous! Though POTU and FFG aren't bad (if not to my taste, exactly). Admittedly, I'd have to take a closer listen at what exactly John Shanks produced as opposed to Sheryl.

I don't know what you mean by sound effects and gizmos :]. . . The strings on EFO? The metronome on GB? The kid chorus on SYW? The sudden tempo shift and enveloping sound on SAY? The Lindsey whispers on RTTG? The drums on Illume? The radical clarity of the cascading guitars on DR and TD? These touches make the songs epic... and work emotionally, expressively in each case.

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848477)
It would be interesting to see what a non-Lindsey-produced FM album would sound like, especially if it is produced by a younger producer who grew up listening to Rumours. It could either be disgustingly, superficially retro or it could be a deconstructed, potent distillation of everything we love about FM.

Well I think Chris Isaak should produce the next album. Mr. Lucky is the most gorgeous American album since. . .

JeannieKartis 10-19-2009 11:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848198)
http://images.dailyexpress.co.uk/img...4/134777_1.jpg

http://www.express.co.uk/entertainment/view/134777

Sunday October 18,2009

IN A frank interview, the Fleetwood Mac star tells CHARLOTTE HEATHCOTE about sex, drugs and rock 'n' roll and how, despite being battered by all three, she's emerged stronger than ever.

Fleetwood Mac are as famed for their in-fighting, feuds and messy, almost incestuous inter-band romances as for Go Your Own Way, Don’t Stop, Everywhere, The Chain and countless other adult-oriented rock songs that have seen them shift more than 100million records.

Stevie Nicks, however, makes absolutely no attempt to put a shiny PR gloss on the legendary tensions.

“We did our first tour and we were p***** off with each other then. We made another record [Rumours] and we were all angry with each other afterwards. We did Tusk and that was 13 months of anger. We did an 18-month tour and by the time that was done everyone was really not speaking...”

She’s half-weary, half-wry. “It’s really nothing new. It’s been happening since time began but if this was a bland, boring band we’d definitely not still be together.”

Stevie and her then-boyfriend Lindsey Buckingham brought a stability of sorts to the shape-shifting line-up of Fleetwood Mac in 1975, joining Mick Fleetwood, John and Christine McVie.

Christine left 11 years ago, ground down by relentless touring, and Stevie misses her ally “every day”.

The other four remain a unit, on the whole, which is especially miraculous when you consider that Stevie and Buckingham’s six-year relationship foundered during the recording of the drug-fuelled Rumours in 1976 (the McVies were splitting at the same time) and, shortly after the Rumours tour, Stevie fell for Fleetwood. They separated for the sake of the band.

By the time of Fleetwood Mac’s last tour, 2003’s Say You Will, Stevie’s relationship with Buckingham had become so fraught that, unless he treated her better this time around, she threatened to walk away “so fast that palm tree tops will fall on his head”.

Now, she says the underlying problem was how much she hated the Say You Will album.

“It was five years ago now so I can say I didn’t like it at all; I didn’t like making it, I didn’t like the songs, so that tour was very hard for me.”

On a Greatest Hits tour, however, there is no new material to quibble over.

“Doing all the very famous material is actually more fun,” insists this born entertainer. “It’s been a breath of fresh air for us to not have to worry about trying to sell [new] songs.”

With five platinum-selling solo records to her name, Stevie is easily the most successful member of Fleetwood Mac. Wasn’t she tempted to walk away during Say You Will?

“Well, I’m a peacemaker and I didn’t want us to break up because the music didn’t go my way. If I’ve learned nothing else in my 61 years it is that four years down the line you’re over it.” She sees the remaining foursome touring for another seven or eight years.

“I’m a performer and an entertainer, that’s what I live for. I would be dancing on tables in bars if I wasn’t in Fleetwood Mac, doing small shows all over the world, driving my van.”

Stevie’s passion for entertaining runs so deep, however, that she admits she has sacrificed all of her romantic relationships for the band but with no regrets.

“My love affair is with my work. I’ve had many wonderful relationships but I could never give up what I do for a relationship; in all of my relationships, at some point, that [prioritising] came up.

“Am I sad about the fact that I don’t have a relationship? No. I’m going to Europe to stay in the best hotels, to play huge shows, playing my music, to meet lots of interesting people. So I really don’t care.”

To Stevie’s amusement, her 81-year-old mother reckons she still hasn’t met Mr Right. She’s all too happy for her mother to be proved right but, to date, the love of her life is a member of the Eagles and not the one you’d expect.

After her split with Buckingham she spent 18 months with Don Henley but, of his bandmate Joe Walsh, she says: “He was the great love of my life. I fell in love with Joe in the same way that Lindsey fell in love with me.”

As their cocaine addiction spiralled out of control in the early Eighties, though, Walsh reluctantly left her for both of their sakes. Now she muses: “Maybe the people you can live best with aren’t the great love of your life; the men you love deeply, the calmer, more loving, more solid people but who you weren’t super passionately crazy in love with. The ones to marry aren’t the ones as crazy as you are.”

Her romance with Walsh was not the only fall-out of her drug addiction. Cocaine has left a hole in her septum, leaving her wishing her generation had not been told that cocaine was “safe, recreational and not a bigger deal than smoking pot or cigarettes”.

A bigger regret is that, after successful treatment for cocaine addiction, her friends persuaded her to see a psychiatrist, hoping this would ensure she avoided a relapse. The doctor prescribed the tranquilliser Klonopin.

“That took eight years out of my life,” she says.

“Those were my prime years, my 40s, when a lot of my heavy, creative activity was really happening. Klonopin grabbed hold of you and made you sit down on your couch and not get up.

“I just watched TV for eight years in a daze. I’m sorry I didn’t have a car crash on the way to seeing that doctor.”

So when Stevie finally got herself back on track, she needed to make up for lost time. “I made a decision a long time ago to follow my artistry. I decided that my mission here on this earth was to write songs for people and make them happy.”

● The UK leg of Fleetwood Mac’s Unleashed tour starts on Thursday and the double CD The Very Best of Fleetwood Mac is out tomorrow.


I honestly did not like Say You Will either......these interviews though are always about the same thing...I guess she has nothing else to talk about...

holidayroad 10-19-2009 11:32 AM

I really like Say You Will. Maybe it doesn't all fit well together, but it has amazing songs. I have to say that I wish everyone in Fleetwood Mac would learn to 'play well with others' (as they should have learned in first grade) and start treating all of this like what it is---their job!!

michelej1 10-19-2009 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TrueFaith77 (Post 848479)
Well I think Chris Isaak should produce the next album. Mr. Lucky is the most gorgeous American album since. . .

I love Chris Isaak, but shudder! Mr. Lucky just does not do it for me. In fact, while he has songs that I consider masterpieces, I don't think consistent albums as a whole are his specialty. His Best Of though, putting all the good stuff together, that leaves me breathless. He's got a lost, dreamy touch made for crooning. Actually, to me, he might have been better for FM when you had Christine, Lindsey and Stevie together. He could do something with them.

Michele

TrueFaith77 10-19-2009 11:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by michelej1 (Post 848485)
I love Chris Isaak, but shudder! Mr. Lucky just does not do it for me. In fact, while he has songs that I consider masterpieces, I don't think consistent albums as a whole are his specialty. His Best Of though, putting all the good stuff together, that leaves me breathless. He's got a lost, dreamy touch made for crooning. Actually, to me, he might have been better for FM when you had Christine, Lindsey and Stevie together. He could do something with them.

Michele

Interesting. I think Mr. Lucky sounds like a Bryan Ferry album. I can make no higher praise.

wheart 10-19-2009 12:04 PM

OK, Stevie, you got off klonopin in 94...time to let it go, seriously. LOL

Interesting about her displeasure with the entire SYW album. I didn't realize she felt quite so strongly, especially about not liking the songs. I wonder which songs, hers or Lindsey's. And was it the songs themselves or the way they turned out? Surely she was pleased with the songs she wrote for the project...so perhaps it was the end result that displeased her. She should have been unhappy with some of her vocals on that record...UGH. On any account, this explains the big old puss she had on her face during the first several months of the SYW tour. :lol:

BellaDonna93 10-19-2009 12:09 PM

I LOVE the Say You Will album, no matter what you think!!!!! :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:

gldstwmn 10-19-2009 01:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC (Post 848198)
http://images.dailyexpress.co.uk/img...4/134777_1.jpg

http://www.express.co.uk/entertainment/view/134777

“Maybe the people you can live best with aren’t the great love of your life; the men you love deeply, the calmer, more loving, more solid people but who you weren’t super passionately crazy in love with."

Bull****. In fact, bull**** to this whole interview. I still find it hard to accept that the man she calls the love of her life called her a "road f*ck." Granted, he was drunk but come on. It's time for Mama to get a new schtick. The reason she isn't with Lindsey today is because she kept telling him no. "You could easily wake up with a stranger, it's not something that you planned. One night in a world of pain and you finally understand. Not all the king's horses, not all the kings men could put it back together."
There must be literally thousands of great stories she could tell but instead she decides to stick with the same old crap. And give me a break about hating Say You Will. I think she's still pissed that Sheryl Crow couldn't/wouldn't join the band.
The only illuminating thing about this whole interview is that Babs Nicks doesn't think she's found the love of her life yet.
And for god's sake, will John grant one interview for this tour. Mick can even be there with him. I just want to hear something different that I never knew about this band for once.

michelej1 10-19-2009 02:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gldstwmn (Post 848509)
And for god's sake, will John grant one interview for this tour. Mick can even be there with him. I just want to hear something different that I never knew about this band for once.

Yeah, what do they say to John? Are they ok with him not doing the publicity or are they frustrated, because that's part of the job and he shouldn't be able to opt out of it? Of course, they all like it if the interviews fit into their schedules (as opposed to the old days when Mick would schedule press conferences when they were all dead tired). The other 3 like to talk, so maybe they don't care if he sits out.

John did participate in that one telephone conference they all did. And he said he argued with Stevie over the "Unleashed" title. But that's it.

Michele


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:32 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
© 1995-2003 Martin and Lisa Adelson, All Rights Reserved