Which ONE FM song should no other artist EVER attempt to cover?

[darklinensuit]

I can see covering classics like Oh Well or Black Magic Woman.

I cannot see remaking a song like SOTM that is just so much in the style of the original artist.

I cannot see remaking a song like Secondhand News, in which the vocals/timing/instruments are already perfect.

I cannot see remaking Christine's simpler songs (like on Tusk) that rely so much on her beautiful voice.

Rod Stewart doing Stand Back is awful --- even more 80s-ish than the original. (Even American Idol Edge of 17 is superior.)

I can live with the Landslide re-makes, and even Courtney doing GDW, but all the Rhiannon covers make me shudder.
Rhiannon should not be touched. Even FM doesn't do it justice anymore, so hands off. Rhiannon is my pick.

- Jake

[gypsysara]

My mind is screaming COME!!!

[tamaraluvsFM]

No one should ever attempt to cover Silver Springs. That is a classic Stevie/Lindsey song.
I would cringe to hear it with someone else's voice.


Tamara :wavey:

[riff_Shuffler]

-SEVEN WONDERS-

*Big time mistake* if any artist were to try to cover this one...

~Josh :nod:

[Sorcerer386]

Speaking of Silver Springs, I'm kind of anxious about hearing this song. I've been so spoiled about EXACTLY how it is done on The Dance cd and video that I can't even get into it on another Dance show that I have. I go to karaoke about 3 nights a week, and usually someone does this song, and it always annoys me because they don't get into the end part. And this one girl who sings it is just terrible (on Silver Springs anyway). So, my vote would go to Silver Springs. Close runner-up IS Rhiannon too, simply because I do not want to hear or see anyone except Stevie doing this song. Even now I love her doing this song, even though everyone else hates it now.

[misterbug]

i don't think any FM song can be successfully covered by any artist. witness the 'rumours' tribute album debacle (well, i thought it was a debacle anyway). i can't think of one song that would be improved by somebody else singing/playing it (ok, i'll admit it, i'm only thinking of the rumours lineup albums and SYW).

[PenguinHead]

My impression is that Lindsey and Stevie have a real quirky, personal musical style, so most of their songs don't have that "Universal Appeal." I stuggle to describe what I mean by that term, but "Landslide" is the one group song that I think approaches it. The Dixie Chicks' version certainly had mass appeal. It's this type of song, with easily accessible lyrics and familiar imagery, that may get (or is) adopted into mass culture.

However, Stevie and Lindsey's work has grown even more idiosychcratic over the years -- which I think is a good thing! But any chances for their newer songs to get covered by other artists seems slim. But who knows? Maybe the Dixie Chicks, giddy with the success of Landslide" might surprise/horrify us and follow it up with a country version of Rhiannon!

[darklinensuit]

Originally posted by PenguinHead
Maybe the Dixie Chicks, giddy with the success of Landslide" might surprise/horrify us and follow it up with a country version of Rhiannon!

Apparently you have not heard the Waylon Jennings version of Rhiannon. Lucky you.

- Jake

[estranged4life]

"Don't Stop", It's bad enough the FM grates my nerves...Won't listen to anyone else's version if it is humanly possible...Brian J.

ps-Besides Waylon Jennings' cool "Rhiannon" cover song, I also like his "Gold Dust Woman" cover....

[Janet]

I agree with Silver Springs. NO ONE should cover that.

[Ali]

I liked Duncan Sheik up until the day he covered "Songbird" and I haven't been able to listen to Eva Cassidy because of it either. That is Christine's song through and through and the only thing that makes me cry more than the song itself is someone attempting to cover such a masterpiece.

[CarneVaca]

The point is not whether a song you consider perfect should ever be covered. The idea is to reinterpret the song in some new way, infuse it with new energy. This is what Camper Van Beethoven did with the remake of the Tusk album. But when you listen to the Rumours tribute, it is pure crap.

Be that as it may, no song is or should be above being reinterpreted by another artist.

[darklinensuit]

Originally posted by CarneVaca
The point is not whether a song you consider perfect should ever be covered. The idea is to reinterpret the song in some new way, infuse it with new energy. This is what Camper Van Beethoven did with the remake of the Tusk album. But when you listen to the Rumours tribute, it is pure crap.

Be that as it may, no song is or should be above being reinterpreted by another artist.

I agree, I just think that some songs present a great challenge in terms of "infusing with new energy". To me, songs like early Rhiannon & 2ndhand News are perfect in their presentation & energy, & artists who try to make it their own are taking a huge gamble. Of course, I respect that that is exactly what artists do. Perhaps another way of phrasing my question would be Which is (probably) the last FM song that could be improved upon by another artist?

- Jake

[sara1998]

I don't like remakes to begin with. But I would absolutely die if anyone tried to remake Sara....

There's no way in hell.

Maria

[macmar71]

I think Sara, I'm So Afraid and Think About Me should never be remade as the originals are by far fabulous and no one could top them.

[Janet]

Really, no songs should be covered.

But any song that is written for a specific person and then covered by someone who has nothing to do with it...it's just wrong.

Thats why I chose SS ...that's wrong.

No one can cover Stevie really because her voice makes an everlasting imprint on a song and changing that changes the entire song. I hate all the covers of Landslide..HATE THEM.

But it's also exciting hearing someone like a song so much that they cover it...so whatever. But no one better touch SS!!!

[CarneVaca]

Janet, you might be surprised as to the number of songs over the years that you like actually turn out to be covers. I would wager you heard "Black Magic Woman" by Santana long before you heard the original.