Entertainment Weekly mentions

[bwboy]

On ew.com there is an article about Danny Kirwan's passing, and in the June 15 issue, "honoring the best musical moments of the past six months," the Best All-Star Replacements- Mike Campbell and Neil Finn in Fleetwood Mac.

[Sugar Mouse]

On ew.com there is an article about Danny Kirwan's passing, and in the June 15 issue, "honoring the best musical moments of the past six months," the Best All-Star Replacements- Mike Campbell and Neil Finn in Fleetwood Mac.

The only all-star replacements I can think of on that level were:

1. Lindsey/Stevie replacing Bob Welch
2. Steve Hogarth replacing Fish in Marillion
3 Phil Collins "replacing" Peter Gabriel in Genesis
4. Trevor Rabin replacing Steve Howe in Yes

[SteveMacD]

The only all-star replacements I can think of on that level were:

1. Lindsey/Stevie replacing Bob Welch

They were hardly all-stars in 1975.

All-star replacements in 1975 would have been Mick Taylor (fresh out of the Rolling Stones) and Ian Gillan (from Deep Purple).

[BombaySapphire3]

Right except for a small pocket of B/N mania in the deep south Stevie and Lindsey were utter unknowns when they got the call on New Year's eve 1974.Stardom at that moment was still a figment of La Nick's imagination.

[Sugar Mouse]

They were hardly all-stars in 1975.

All-star replacements in 1975 would have been Mick Taylor (fresh out of the Rolling Stones) and Ian Gillan (from Deep Purple).

I guess it depends on whether they mean "all stars" before, after, or either joining the band.

[secondhandchain]

On ew.com there is an article about Danny Kirwan's passing, and in the June 15 issue, "honoring the best musical moments of the past six months," the Best All-Star Replacements- Mike Campbell and Neil Finn in Fleetwood Mac.

Why is this in the Rumours forum? Still not going to make me care about the new line up. Cashgrab Mac

[SteveMacD]

Why is this in the Rumours forum? Still not going to make me care about the new line up. Cashgrab Mac

Because the mods said it was okay to talk about the current lineup here. Sorry you didn’t get the memo.

[bwboy]

Why is this in the Rumours forum? Still not going to make me care about the new line up. Cashgrab Mac

Sorry you don't think Danny Kirwan's passing belongs in this board. Some fans would be interested in knowing this, whether he was a member of the Rumours band or not. Since you don't care that he died, feel free to simply ignore this thread, along with another one that mentions Billy Burnette is doing better after having a heart attack and is now out of the hospital. I understand you probably don't care about Billy either, but other fans here do.

[SteveMacD]

Sorry you don't think Danny Kirwan's passing belongs in this board. Some fans would be interested in knowing this, whether he was a member of the Rumours band or not. Since you don't care that he died, feel free to simply ignore this thread, along with another one that mentions Billy Burnette is doing better after having a heart attack and is now out of the hospital. I understand you probably don't care about Billy either, but other fans here do.

I think the objection was more about the Campbell/Finn reference. Not that anyone GAF about whether or not secondhandchain cares about the new lineup.

[jbrownsjr]

They were hardly all-stars in 1975.

All-star replacements in 1975 would have been Mick Taylor (fresh out of the Rolling Stones) and Ian Gillan (from Deep Purple).

Not to mention Phil Coliins wasn't an all star either. He was barely a singer. He just happened to have some acting and a bit of singing experience and in a weird way sounded like Gabriel.

[SteveMacD]

Not to mention Phil Coliins wasn't an all star either. He was barely a singer. He just happened to have some acting and a bit of singing experience and in a weird way sounded like Gabriel.

And, already being their drummer and backing vocalist didn’t hurt his cause.

[Sugar Mouse]

Not to mention Phil Coliins wasn't an all star either. He was barely a singer. He just happened to have some acting and a bit of singing experience and in a weird way sounded like Gabriel.

Phil Collins was considered one of the best drummers in the world at the time when he replaced Peter Gabriel as lead singer.

[jbrownsjr]

Phil Collins was considered one of the best drummers in the world at the time when he replaced Peter Gabriel as lead singer.

Drummer, yes. Singer, no.

[secondhandchain]

I think the objection was more about the Campbell/Finn reference. Not that anyone GAF about whether or not secondhandchain cares about the new lineup.

Um....I'm not the ONLY ONE who doesn't care about the new line up. There are tons of us. And yes I was not referring to Kirwan. RIP.

[HomerMcvie]

Sorry you don't think Danny Kirwan's passing belongs in this board. Some fans would be interested in knowing this, whether he was a member of the Rumours band or not. Since you don't care that he died, feel free to simply ignore this thread, along with another one that mentions Billy Burnette is doing better after having a heart attack and is now out of the hospital. I understand you probably don't care about Billy either, but other fans here do.

Danny doesn't belong on THIS forum.

Billy doesn't belong on THIS forum.

There's nothing wrong with following the rules here.

You've been noticeably absent for a week or more here. I hope you had a nice vacation.:angel:

[HomerMcvie]

Um....I'm not the ONLY ONE who doesn't care about the new line up. There are tons of us. And yes I was not referring to Kirwan. RIP.

Preach it, preach it! I wouldn't go see this lineup if the ticket was free.

[iamnotafraid]

Preach it, preach it! I wouldn't go see this lineup if the ticket was free.

I wouldn't go see this lineup if they paid me.

David did you happen to read CNN's post about
Danny Kirwan? If not look it up and tell me who
shows up in the article about him. Playing guitar
no less.

Leave it to CNN.

[lennonfan]

to make this thread have some relation to rumors, word is going round a Swedish woman who had a relationship with Danny back in the early Mac years kept in touch and said that his family had taken good care of him and that his situation wasn't dire.
God bless Danny Kirwan. Beautiful music from a sensitive soul.

[HomerMcvie]

I wouldn't go see this lineup if they paid me.

David did you happen to read CNN's post about
Danny Kirwan? If not look it up and tell me who
shows up in the article about him. Playing guitar
no less.

Leave it to CNN.

I did not see it. If you find a link, please post it.

What do y'all think Danny's biggest problem was?
Alcoholism?
Mental illness?
A combination of both?

[SisterNightroad]

I did not see it. If you find a link, please post it.

What do y'all think Danny's biggest problem was?
Alcoholism?
Mental illness?
A combination of both?
For some mental diseases there's a link between the use of psychotropic substances and the manifestation of the pathology, however what did Danny suffer from? I've never seen any source mention it

[HomerMcvie]

For some mental diseases there's a link between the use of psychotropic substances and the manifestation of the pathology, however what did Danny suffer from? I've never seen any source mention it

I've always personally believed that it was mostly alcoholism, although with a bit of mental issues thrown in(probably never professionally addressed).

There's a Danny FB fan page that I've followed for years, that the "owner" seems to have gone off the deep end, since Danny's death.

https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=10155573841294646&id=350216134645

https://www.facebook.com/Danny-Kirwan-350216134645/

[SisterNightroad]

I've always personally believed that it was mostly alcoholism, although with a bit of mental issues thrown in(probably never professionally addressed).

There's a Danny FB fan page that I've followed for years, that the "owner" seems to have gone off the deep end, since Danny's death.

https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=10155573841294646&id=350216134645

https://www.facebook.com/Danny-Kirwan-350216134645/
Yes, I've seen that page and somewhere once there they were saying that at some point Danny had ended at a homeless facility for people with mental illness if I'm not mistaken.
However yes, the administrator seems to be on a rampage, I guess this is the post they're referring to in your first link, I see a resemblance to the current times:

<iframe src="https://www.facebook.com/plugins/post.php?href=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2Fpermalink.php%3Fstory_fbid%3D10155573259469646%26id%3 D350216134645&width=500" width="500" height="288" style="border:none;overflow:hidden" scrolling="no" frameborder="0" allowTransparency="true" allow="encrypted-media"></iframe>