This or That - Fleetwood Mac style

[TheWILDheart]

Hi everyone,

Thought this might be fun - it's happening in the Stevie forum, so thought I'd start a Fleetwood Mac one too. A few forums I'm on have done this for different things and it's pretty interesting.

Just pick your favourite out of the two choices the previous user writes.

For example, if I post:

Little Lies or Everywhere

Then the next person picks their favourite, and posts 2 choices and so on and so on....

Not limited to songs either, it can be anything related to Stevie and her career, providing there is an OR involved lol.

Ready?

GO!

[TheWILDheart]

I shall start us of...

Bleed To Love Her or My Little Demon?

[KenB]

Bleed to Love Her is a beautiful, perfectly layered statement of vulnerability. My Little Demon is a repetitive mess.

Hold Me or Little Lies?

[WatchChain]

"HOLD ME"

"Sara" OR "Welcome To The Room...Sara"

[TheWILDheart]

oh that's easy, "Sara".

Shakin' The Cage tour or Behind The Mask tour?

[James89]

Easy. The '87 'Shake the cage' tour.

'Eyes of The World' from 'Live In Boston' OR 'Blue Letter' from 1982......

[ViscountViktor]

Eyes of the World.

Second Hand News or Monday Morning

[michelej1]

Second Hand News.

Heart of Stone or Behind the Mask

[FuzzyPlum]

Not much in it... but Behind The Mask.

Tusk sides 1&2
or
Tusk sides 3&4

[He's So Unusual]

Tusk sides 1&2

Why or Songbird

[WatchChain]

TOUGH ONE !!!

"SONGBIRD"

Rick Vito OR Billy Burnett

[PenguinHead]

Rick Vito

Danny Kirwan or Jeremy Spencer

[ViscountViktor]

Danny Kirwan

Blues era or Rumours era

[James89]

That's ridiculous on a Rumours forum.

Of course Rumours.

[louielouie2000]

That's ridiculous on a Rumours forum.

Of course Rumours.

You aren't playing according to the rules... it's your turn to ask this or that? :D

[TheWILDheart]

Brown Eyes or Over & Over?

[WatchChain]

"Brown Eyes"

Christine McVie Exes

Dennis Wilson OR Eddy Quintela

[James89]

Eddy Quintela.

'Thrown Down' or 'Destiny Rules'......

[michelej1]

Thrown Down

Oh Daddy or Sugar Daddy

[Johnny Stew]

"Oh Daddy"

Dave Walker or Dave Mason

[bombaysaffires]

oh Daddy.

Bearded, curly-hair Lindsey (Rumours era) or shorn Lindsey (Tusk and later)?

[WatchChain]

Bearded curly haired Lindsey!

STEVIE HAIR

70's Shag OR 80's Big Hairweave Extensions

[Iamwilliame]

70s shag

Rumours or Tusk

[WatchChain]

TUSK !! Hands down, no competition!!

Mirage OR Tango In The Night

[KenB]

Mirage, no contest. It's the band's most underappreciated gem.

Joan Of Arc, or Down Endless Street?

[Johnny Stew]

"Joan of Arc"

And I'll ask again:

Dave Walker or Dave Mason

[WatchChain]

DAVE WALKER for recording Fleetwood Mac's phenomenal track
"The Derelict"....love the harmonica !! Rock on, Penguin !!!

Bekka Bramlett OR Stevie Nicks

(lol, sorry, couldn't resist......):laugh:

[MikeInNV]

DAVE WALKER for recording Fleetwood Mac's phenomenal track
"The Derelict"....love the harmonica !! Rock on, Penguin !!!

Bekka Bramlett OR Stevie Nicks

(lol, sorry, couldn't resist......):laugh:

Stevie Nicks.

Fireflies or The Farmer's Daughter?

[teedeerocks]

Stevie Nicks.

Fireflies or The Farmer's Daughter?

Fireflies!! Stevie sober or Stevie wacky?

[michelej1]

Stevie sober

Mirage Album Cover or Dance album Cover

[Montclare]

Mirage album cover. My all time favorite album cover of theirs. The Dance one looks awkward.

Storms or Mick's bio?

[Iamwilliame]

Bio

Don't say that you love me or just tell me that you want me?

[louielouie2000]

Don't say that you love me or just tell me that you want me?

Just Tell Me That You Want Me.

Lindsey's (insane) loves-

Carol Ann or Anne Heche? :cool:

[Johnny Stew]

Anne Heche (she at least has some talent)

"Wish You Were Here" or "Only Over You"

[Danigirl]

Only Over You

Rumours backstage footage or Tusk Documentary.

[teedeerocks]

Anne Heche (she at least has some talent)

"Wish You Were Here" or "Only Over You"

Bucky or DS (producing)? Almost forgot - Wish You Were Here!

[bombaysaffires]

Only Over You

Rumours backstage footage or Tusk Documentary.

Tusk documentary

Bucky or DS (producing)? Almost forgot - Wish You Were Here!
Bucky!

Tree backdrop on stage (early BN days with the band) or that alien spaceship thing from the Dance?

[HelloMonster]

Tusk documentary


Bucky!

Tree backdrop on stage (early BN days with the band) or that alien spaceship thing from the Dance?

Tree backdrop

SOTM or Straight Back?

[bombaysaffires]

Tree backdrop

SOTM or Straight Back?

Sisters, esp live

Lindsey's white 70s suit, or jeans and stretched out tee shirt?

[Nickingham]

Sisters, esp live

Lindsey's white 70s suit, or jeans and stretched out tee shirt?

Jeans and stretched out tee shirt (although Lindsey did look good in the suit).


Which hat do you prefer John in?

Baseball cap or Ivy cap

[FuzzyPlum]

Which hat do you prefer John in?

Baseball cap or Ivy cap

Baseball cap

When I See You Again or The Second Time

[gssmith]

Jeans and stretched out tee shirt (although Lindsey did look good in the suit).


Which hat do you prefer John in?

Baseball cap or Ivy cap

Ivy cap.

Tusk from the dance or mirage video?

[TheWILDheart]

The Second Time.

Tusk from The Dance.

Mirage Live or Tusk Doc?

[ViscountViktor]

Mirage Live

Little Lies or Everywhere

[tz5632]

Everywhere!

Family Man (Extended Guitar Remix) or Family Man (Extended Vocal Remix)?

:)

[teedeerocks]

Everywhere!

Family Man (Extended Guitar Remix) or Family Man (Extended Vocal Remix)?

:)

Extended guitar.Chatty Stevie or reserved Stevie?

[TheWILDheart]

Chatty Stevie.

Peacekeeper or Sad Angel?

[lulu28]

Sad Angel

Stevie in all black or Stevie wearing different colors??

[gssmith]

Sad Angel

Stevie in all black or Stevie wearing different colors??

All black. Maybe a slight dash of color, but all black.

Stevie or Lindsey? Hahaha

[Montclare]

Lindsey.

Stevie's top hat or Lindsey's Mirage hat?

[TheWILDheart]

Lindsey's Mirage hat. Everytime I watch that video I want to lick him. Everywhere.

Can't Go Back or I Know I'm Not Wrong?

[James89]

I know I'm Not Wrong.

Lindsey 1977 or Lindsey 1979.....

[ViscountViktor]

Lindsey 1977

John or Mick

[sanders8323]

Mick.

Empire State or Oh Diane?

[TheWILDheart]

Empire State.

Love Shines or As Long As You Follow?

[bombaysaffires]

Empire State.

Love Shines or As Long As You Follow?

As Long as you Follow


Lindsey 1977

John or Mick

I'm gonna go with John.

Richard Dashut/Ken Caillat production team, or Lindsey producing alone?

[WatchChain]

Dashut/Caillat ALL THE WAY !!!

"Mystery to Me" OR "Heroes Are Hard To Find"

[moon]

Mystery to Me!!! :nod:

Think About Me or Love in Store?

[PenguinHead]

Mystery to Me!!! :nod:

Think About Me or Love in Store?

Hard choice!

Think About Me


Mirage concert video or Say You Will concert dvd

[WatchChain]

Mirage Concert Video---Sisters of the Moon ROCKS !!!!

Fleetwood Mac Live Concerts:

PRE-1987--5 Members ONLY with occasional guitar from Ray Lindsey

OR

POST-1987--Supporting musicians, backup singers, percussion player, Neale Haywood, Brett Tuggle, Taku Hirano, Asante, Sharon Celani, Elisecia Wright, Lori Nicks, Mindy Stein, Jana Anderson, Carlos Rios, etc...

[louielouie2000]

PRE-1987--5 Members ONLY with occasional guitar from Ray Lindsey

OR

POST-1987--Supporting musicians, backup singers, percussion player, Neale Haywood, Brett Tuggle, Taku Hirano, Asante, Sharon Celani, Elisecia Wright, Lori Nicks, Mindy Stein, Jana Anderson, Carlos Rios, etc...

Pre '87... everything since has sounded like a Broadway rendition of Fleetwood Mac.

Christine's '84 solo album OR In The Meantime?

[FuzzyPlum]

Christine's '84 solo album OR In The Meantime?

In The Meantime

Record Plant or Village Recorder

[WayOfTheDragon]

Village Recorder.

"You & I, Part One" or "Ricky"?

[He's So Unusual]

You & I, Part One

Landslide 1975 or Landslide 1997

[WayOfTheDragon]

Landslide 1997.

Big Love acoustic or Big Love album version?

[James89]

Has to be Big Love album version even though I admire Lindsey's talent on the live version. I just prefer to listen to the album version.

'My Little Demon' or 'Temporary One'.....

[Montclare]

Temporary One. I'd go with My Little Demon if it didn't have the weird noises.

Hold Me video or Gypsy video?

[michelej1]

Hold Me video.

Make Me a Mask or Goodbye Angel

[jbrownsjr]

ewwwww... umm... Make Me A Mask I guess... lol

I'm So Afraid (FMac Live) (Cleveland) 1980ish or
I'm So Afraid (FMac Live Mirage Tour Los Angeles) 1982

[moon]

I'm So Afraid (Live 1980). One of the best versions ever.
Well,

Angel or Gypsy?

[WayOfTheDragon]

Angel.

Future Games or Bare Trees?

[TheWILDheart]

Bare Trees.

In The Back Of My Mind or Talkin' To My Heart?

[jbrownsjr]

Bare Trees.

In The Back Of My Mind or Talkin' To My Heart?

In The Back Of My Mind

Bad Loser or Prove Your Love

[louielouie2000]

Bad Loser or Prove Your Love

Prove Your Love :nod:

Hypnotized or Future Games (song)?

[ViscountViktor]

Tough one! I'll go with Hypnotized.

Live 1980 or The Dance

[WatchChain]

Call me crazy, but I prefer Fleetwood Mac Live (1980). It has a much more raw, authentic feel and captures the true essence of hearing this band play live. Don't get me wrong, there are some phenomenal moments on THE DANCE (the amazing "Silver Springs", being one), but the 1997 live album with backup singers and extra musicians has a somewhat manufactured sound, almost like a studio record (think Stevie Nicks: The Soundstage Sessions). "Rhiannon", "Sara" and "I'm So Afraid" from Fleetwood Mac Live (1980) are some of best moments this band has put on record.

Spare Me A Little of Your Love OR Come A Little Bit Closer

[James89]

Thanks to what it's done for them since, The Dance.

I'm So Afraid live 1997 or Come from Live in Boston.....

[Montclare]

Spare Me A Little of Your Love OR Come A Little Bit Closer

Thanks to what it's done for them since, The Dance.

I'm So Afraid live 1997 or Come from Live in Boston.....

Yea, I get two for the price of one!

Spare Me a Little
I'm So Afraid 1997

Lindsey's cow kimono or John's short shorts?

[MacFan77]

Rumours

Go Your Own Way or The Chain

[jbrownsjr]

Rumours

Go Your Own Way or The Chain

The Chain

Rock A Little or Other Side of The Mirror

[gypsyhelena]

Rock A Little.

Vinyl or CD?

[WayOfTheDragon]

VINYL!

Mirage Tour video or Tusk Documentary?

[TheWILDheart]

Tusk doc.

Stevie & Christine's harmonies on "Skies The Limit" or "Straight Back"?

[tz5632]

Skies the limit!

Warm ways or Sugar Daddy?

[WatchChain]

Yea, I get two for the price of one!

Lindsey's cow kimono or John's short shorts?


JOHN'S SHORT SHORTS----John McVie sporting a pair of Daisy Dukes with a cool pothead 70's attitude is enough to make anyone swoon!

WARM WAYS!!! (By the way, was this written about John McVie or Martin Birch??)




Honey Hi OR BROWN EYES

[ViscountViktor]

Brown eyes

Ken Caillat or Richard Dashut

[TheWILDheart]

Richard.

"Time" or "Penguin"?

[welcomechris]

Richard.

"Time" or "Penguin"?

Penguin, by far

Skies the Limit or I Do

[TheWILDheart]

"Skies The Limit", though I do like "I Do".

"Go Insane" in a Fleetwood Mac set or "Stand Back" in a Fleetwood Mac set?

[louielouie2000]

"Go Insane" in a Fleetwood Mac set or "Stand Back" in a Fleetwood Mac set?

Despite the fact Stand Back is a much needed injection of high energy into the setlist, Go Insane is just so gorgeous, moody, and atmospheric. It fits in with the classic Mac sound beautifully.


Bleed To Love Her from The Dance or Bleed To Love Her from Say You Will?

[michelej1]

Bleed To Love Her from The Dance or Bleed To Love Her from Say You Will?

The Dance. BTLH never should have been on SYW.

Sentimental Lady on Bare Trees or Sentimental Lady on French Kiss

[teedeerocks]

The Dance. BTLH never should have been on SYW.

Sentimental Lady on Bare Trees or Sentimental Lady on French Kiss

Sentimental Lady on French Kiss. Rock & Roll or Crash Into Me (covers)?

[Aussie W/Heart]

Sentimental Lady on French Kiss. Rock & Roll or Crash Into Me (covers)?

Crash Into Me

Playing Live
With back up musicians & singers or just the five fireflies?

[Montclare]

Definitely just the five. I especially find in odd in videos when they do close ups on the non-Mac members. I'm not watching for them.

Cooler brother-in-law-George Harrison or Eric Clapton?

[jbrownsjr]

Definitely just the five. I especially find in odd in videos when they do close ups on the non-Mac members. I'm not watching for them.

Cooler brother-in-law-George Harrison or Eric Clapton?

Clapton

I Don't Wanna Know or Second Hand News

[gypsyhelena]

I Don't Wanna Know.

Unedited album version of Sara, or the Cleaning Lady demo?

[Danigirl]

I Don't Wanna Know.

Unedited album version of Sara, or the Cleaning Lady demo?

Cleaning Lady Sara

Lindsey's "Trouble" or B-Side "I'll Tell You Now?"

[michelej1]

Cleaning Lady Sara

Lindsey's "Trouble" or B-Side "I'll Tell You Now?"

Trouble.

Dancing Across the USA or Holiday Road

[WayOfTheDragon]

Holiday Road.

Teen Beat or Cool Water?

[Stormwind]

Holiday Road.

Teen Beat or Cool Water?

Teen Beat.

"Big Love" or "Doing What I can"?

[Johnny Stew]

"Doing What I Can" (been listening to that song lately)

"Big Love" remix or "Family Man" remix

[moon]

Family Man remix, and even when I don't like the Tango remixes, the guitar version of this song is nice.

Greatest Hits or The Very Best Of?

[gssmith]

Family Man remix, and even when I don't like the Tango remixes, the guitar version of this song is nice.

Greatest Hits or The Very Best Of?

I like the liner notes for GH 1988 better. But I'd go with the very best of only because it was a double album that can properly cover thier best work. A few nice rare songs too.

Who would be better in bed: mick or Lindsey?

[Aussie W/Heart]

I like the liner notes for GH 1988 better. But I'd go with the very best of only because it was a double album that can properly cover thier best work. A few nice rare songs too.

Who would be better in bed: mick or Lindsey?

lol, that's an easier one for Stevie to answer

But id say LB

Best album cover Rumours or Tango In The Night

[He's So Unusual]

Rumours

Live 1980 or The Dance?

[WayOfTheDragon]

Live 1980.

"Never Make Me Cry" or "Never Forget"?

[Montclare]

Never Make Me Cry.

Album version of Not that Funny or Mirage tour version of it?

[Danigirl]

Never Make Me Cry.

Album version of Not that Funny or Mirage tour version of it?

Live Mirage version!

Micks' World Turning Drum solo or Not That Funny (82') drum solo?

[dontlookdown]

Not That Funny drum solo.
Unless you mean the very early World Turning drum solos with the bongo (75-78).
Don't like the current World Turning drum solo very much.



Sara or Gypsy?

[bombaysaffires]

Not That Funny drum solo.
Unless you mean the very early World Turning drum solos with the bongo (75-78).
Don't like the current World Turning drum solo very much.



Sara or Gypsy?

Love 'em both, but I'll go with Gypsy.

Best Christine/Lindsey collaboration:

Think About Me or Hold Me

[michelej1]

This is hard because I think Hold Me is best, but Think About Me is so overlooked that I always want to vote for it.

THINK ABOUT ME

Ricky or Cool Water?

[WayOfTheDragon]

Ricky.

When I See You Again or The Second Time?

[jbrownsjr]

When I See You Again

Perfect or McVie

[bombaysaffires]

When I See You Again

Perfect or McVie

McVie.

Christine boyfriend: Curry Grant or Dennis Wilson

[Johnny Stew]

Hmm, Curry Grant -- just because Dennis seemed to treat Chris pretty poorly.

"Why" or "Songbird"

[bombaysaffires]

Hmm, Curry Grant -- just because Dennis seemed to treat Chris pretty poorly.

"Why" or "Songbird"


Why.

John drinking or sober?

[jbrownsjr]

Why.

John drinking or sober?

Drinking...

Sister's of the Moon 1982 live or Sisters of the Moon 2013 live..

[bombaysaffires]

Drinking...

Sister's of the Moon 1982 live or Sisters of the Moon 2013 live..

1982. can't beat a coke-fueled Stevie performance


Christine's Butter Cookie/Keep Me There or Keep Me There with Vocal?

[jbrownsjr]

1982. can't beat a coke-fueled Stevie performance


Christine's Butter Cookie/Keep Me There or Keep Me There with Vocal?

Butter Cookie.. the piano is awesome! vocal.. not so much..

[bombaysaffires]

Butter Cookie.. the piano is awesome! vocal.. not so much..

you forgot to throw down the next challenge!

[jbrownsjr]

you forgot to throw down the next challenge!

Good lord! so sorry...

Bwana or Mary Lee Jones

[sodascouts]

Mary Lee Jones (Bwana is just a bit too over the top for me)

================

Buckingham Nicks' "Crystal" or Fleetwood Mac's "Crystal"

[bombaysaffires]

Mary Lee Jones (Bwana is just a bit too over the top for me)

================

Buckingham Nicks' "Crystal" or Fleetwood Mac's "Crystal"

Fleetwood Mac's.

Band Big Love or Lindsey solo Big Love?

[Johnny Stew]

These days, I prefer the full-band version.

"Wrong" or "I Know I'm Not Wrong"

[jbrownsjr]

These days, I prefer the full-band version.

"Wrong" or "I Know I'm Not Wrong"

Wrong (because it's a funny video)

Stop Draggin or I Will Run To You

[bombaysaffires]

Wrong (because it's a funny video)

Stop Draggin or I Will Run To You

Stop Draggin.

Oh Well or Hypotized?

[jbrownsjr]

Stop Draggin.

Oh Well or Hypotized?

Oh Well (off Then Play On)

Danny or Jeremy