Rumours - Analyze Your Least Favorites

[MacShadowsBall]

Time to move onto Rumours. I know this album has been discussed around 4,000 times, so here's 4,001! :laugh:

Sick to death of -

The forgotten about little song that could -

Doesn't belong on Rumours -

Everybody else likes em, but not me -

Much better peformed live -

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album?


Overall least favorite -

[HomerMcvie]

Sick to death of - Dreams

The forgotten about little song that could - IDWTK!!!!

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Silver Bed Springs

Everybody else likes em, but not me - There's really nothing I hate on here - I'm tired of them all!:laugh:

Much better peRformed live - YMLF

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album?- You can't rewrite history, no matter how big a ditz you are.


Overall least favorite - Dreams

[bluefox4000]

Sick to death of Don't Stop

The forgotten about little song that could Oh Daddy

Doesn't Belong on Rumours Hmmmm tough one.....Gosh.....Don't know

Everybody else likes, Not me You Make Loving Fun

Much better performed Live Gold Dust Woman

Should Silver Springs have been on the album? No. It's a pretty down album already SS would have made it to down.

Overall least favorite I don't want to know.

Mick

[RickRobert]

Sick to death of - Dreams

The forgotten about little song that could - Second Hand News? :shrug:

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Gold Dust Woman... not at the end anyway...

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Gold Dust Woman

Much better peformed live - The Chain

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? - Sure

Overall least favorite - Gold Dust Woman

[louielouie2000]

Sick to death of - Go Your Own Way/Don't Stop

The forgotten about little song that could - Does this album have any song that's not famous and well known? :shrug: I adore Oh Daddy, but most people seem to hate that one... does that count?

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Silver Springs. Great song, wrong album. Mick was right.

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Don't Stop. I find it cheesy.

Much better peformed live - These songs are all great live and on the album.

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? No.

Overall least favorite - Don't Stop.

[Fiver]

Sick to death of - None

The forgotten about little song that could - Oh Daddy, but I've always loved it. IDWTK is a close runner-up.

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Silver Springs is kinda the only answer here, right? I first heard the remastered Rumours on CD, with it at track 7. I assumed it was always on there. Works for me.

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Huh... nothing doing, I likes em all!

Much better performed live - I wouldn't say MUCH better, but I really enjoy live versions of YMLF

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? - Not sure. Arguably worked out better that it wasn't.

Overall least favorite - Don't Stop, but it's still good.

[fumidesigns]

Sick to death of - Don't stop

The forgotten about little song that could - i don't wanna know

Doesn't belong on Rumours - they all belong there if ya ask me, but since i have to pick.........Oh Daddy

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Oh Daddy

Much better peformed live - GYOW

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? naw. leave it as is


Overall least favorite -Oh Daddy

[CreepingDeath]

Sick to death of - Go Your Own Way. Lindsey's overkill performances live have made me very sick of it.

The forgotten about little song that could - I Don't Want To know

Doesn't belong on Rumours - I think they all belong, really. :shrug:

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Don't Stop

Much better peformed live - The Chain

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? - Yes.

Overall least favorite - Don't Stop

[tilthefirefades]

Sick to death of - Dreams

The forgotten about little song that could - Oh Daddy

Doesn't belong on Rumours -

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Gold Dust Woman, I like it but not as much as everyone else.

Much better peformed live - The Chain

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? Yes


Overall least favorite - I Don't Wanna Know

[Dark Angel]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop

The forgotten about little song that could - IDWTK

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Silver Springs

Everybody else likes em, but not me - don't know

Much better peformed live - GYOW or The Chain

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? No


Overall least favorite - Don't Stop

[KarmaContestant]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop

The forgotten about little song that could - I Don't Wanna Know

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Oh Daddy

Everybody else likes em, but not me - I got nothing here

Much better peformed live - Go Your own Way

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? Absolutely, yes.

Overall least favorite - Don't Stop

[Spoinny]

[QUOTE=MacShadowsBall;966831]Time to move onto Rumours. I know this album has been discussed around 4,000 times, so here's 4,001! :laugh:

[B]Sick to death of - Dreams, live by Stevie, Live by FM, on the radio, ANYWHERE

The forgotten about little song that could - Never Going Back Again

Doesn't belong on Rumours - they ALL belong there, yes, even Oh Daddy

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Dreams

Much better peformed live - Gold Dust Woman

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? No. I may be in the minority, but I believe the Dance Version is superior.

Overall least favorite - Oh Daddy

[TrueFaith77]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop. Not really sick to death of it, BUT: Clinton ruined it and Stevie & Lindsey should let it go.

The forgotten about little song that could - Oh Daddy - probably my second fav Christine track OF ALL TIME

Doesn't belong on Rumours - This is such a set-up for IDWTK. BUT IT BELONGS ON RUMOURS. If The Chain is Side 2's GYW then IDWTK is Side 2's SHN--or vice versa :lol:

Everybody else likes em, but not me - hmmmm... I prefer Sisters of the Moon to Gold Dust Woman.

Much better peformed live - Gold Dust Woman is so epic when you're there in person! It's also my mom's favorite Stevie song.

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? NO!!!!!!!!!


Overall least favorite - Gosh... NGBA vs. IDWTK vs. Don't Stop/Songbird??? ... I D W T K the answer! BUT I think I have to go with Don't Stop and blaming Bill Clinton.

[Sleepless-Child]

Sick to death of - Probably the whole album. I can only answer not Dreams.

The forgotten about little song that could - Never Going Back Again is the closest to be a "forgotten" song i like.

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Why this question for the Rumours album?

Everybody else likes em, but not me - GOLD DUST WOMAN. (don't like Sisters of the Moon that much too, though).

Much better peformed live - Don't Stop. Or maybe Never Going Back Again.
The songs on Rumours are so studio-perfect...

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? I don't care. We heard it like a million times now, so what's the difference anyway?

Overall least favorite - Second Hand News. This song is overrated.

[ButterCookie]

Sick to death of - Dreams

The forgotten about little song that could - Could what?

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Silver Springs

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Dreams

Much better peformed live - Don't Stop

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? No


Overall least favorite - Dreams

[astro-addy]

Sick to death of - None of them, I still love listening to the album start to finish!

The forgotten about little song that could - I don't wanna know, in a way it saves the album, propping it up a little at the end.

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Oh Daddy, I havent liked this song since the first time I ever heard the opening chord.

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Songbird, I really dont think much of the vocal.

Much better peformed live - Gold Dust Woman is hypnotic live.

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? This one is a toughy, I always assumed SS would have replaced Oh Daddy, in which case i would be all for it! But I recently discovered it would have been in the place of IDWK, (I always just assumed it was a Lindsey song) in light of this, I'm glad they saved SS for the Dance.

[markolas]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop (please for god's sake, stop!)

The forgotten about little song that could - Are any of these songs really forgotten about? I Don't Want to Know might fit the bill, but the others are all fairly well known.

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Don't Stop (just kill it, pls)

Everybody else likes em, but not me - I'd say Don't Stop, but I'm not sure if everybody else does actually like it.

Much better peformed live - The Chain

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? I'm gonna say yes, although if it had been included, The Dance version wouldn't have had the same impact it did. But really, given the choice between Don't Stop and Silver Springs, it's Silver Springs by a Landslide :p.

Overall least favorite - Don't Stop (ick)

[caroline79]

Sick to death of - Of all the FM music I have heard (so far) the music on Rumours is probably what I have listened to the LEAST! I don't know why but because of that I'm not really sick of any of them.

The forgotten about little song that could - Hmmm...tie between I Don't Want To Know and Never Going Back Again :nod:

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Songbird? :shrug:

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Oh Daddy . It's okay just not a favorite.

Much better peformed live - The Chain with out a doubt. :thumbsup:


Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? This one is a toughy, I always assumed SS would have replaced Oh Daddy, in which case i would be all for it! But I recently discovered it would have been in the place of IDWK, (I always just assumed it was a Lindsey song) in light of this, I'm glad they saved SS for the Dance.


Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album?- ^ If that is true then I am going to have to say no!

Overall least favorite - Songbird

[Artemis]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop

The forgotten about little song that could - Oh Daddy. I Don't Want To Know.

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Never Going Back Again.

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Don't Stop. Never Going Back Again

Much better peformed live - Gold Dust Woman. The Chain (Only on the Mirage tour)

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? Yes. Yes. Yes.

Overall least favorite - Don't Stop.

[chazlightyear]

Sick to death of - Dreams

The Forgotten little song that could - Oh Daddy

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Silver Springs

Everyone else likes em but not me - I like them all really just tired of Dreams and Don't stop as it's all that gets played here

Much better performed live - Never going back again

Should Silver Springs been on the Rumours album - Definitely not, IDWTK fits the flow of the album much better

Overall least favourite - Songbird I don't hate it but it's probably my least listened to

[mezzoforte]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop.

The forgotten about little song that could - I don't know that I'd call Never Going Back Again forgotten (is anything on Rumours forgotten?), but it doesn't get as much attention as it deserves, imo. Definitely my favorite LB song on the album.

Doesn't belong on Rumours -

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Dreams. It's not even that I'm tired of it--I've always considered it really bland. Like, it always takes me a minute to remember the tune. Even after hearing it 1000 times. And GYOW has never done much for me--I find the chorus really grating, but enjoy the verses and guitar bits.

Much better peformed live - Don't Stop. It's really only the studio version that sends me batty; I still kind of like live recordings.

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? No. It's probably my favorite FM song of all time and infinitely better than IDWK, but how could I want to lose what was possibly the greatest moment in FM history? I speak, of course, of the Dance: it wouldn't have had anything like the impact it had, had it been on Rumours.


Overall least favorite - Don't Stop

[McTrouble]

Sick To Death Of: Dreams

The Forgotten About Little Song: I Don't Want To Know

Doesn't Belong On Rumours: Oh Daddy

Everybody Else, But Not Me: Songbird

Much Better Performed Live: All of them!!!!!

Should Silver Springs Have Been Included: No opinion either way

Overall Least Favourite: Oh Daddy

[darklinensuit]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop & Go Your Own Way. Not quite as sick of Dreams as I was a few years ago.

The forgotten about little song that could - I Don't Want to Know

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Songbird

Everybody else likes em, but not me - You Make Loving Fun. I like it more now than I used to, but I think Chris has put out far better songs than this one. An for a long time I could not make out the part where sings the words "I never did" before "believe" - granted, this is a production issue, & not Chris's fault.

Much better performed live - The Chain

Should "Silver Springs" have been on the Rumours album? Yes


Overall least favorite - Don't Stop, though I admit the album would be darker and might have been less popular without it - which in the long run might be a good thing :)


- Jake

[windbecame]

Sick to death of - probably none??
forgotten little song that could - I Don't Want to Know
Doesn't belong on Rumours - oh daddy
Everbody else likes em but not me - oh daddy
much better live - The Chain(back in the day) Never Goin Back Again(now)
Should S.S have been on Rumours - I guess no but we have the reissue so...
overall least favorite - oh daddy. Chris already had Sonbird..i never understood why she got another slow song on this album? Never dug this song at all sorry. tho i DO like the outtake with Stevie harmony on it!:thumbsup:

[WildHearted]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop

The forgotten about little song that could - I Don't Wanna Know

Doesn't belong on Rumours - I just can't. I don't like Oh Daddy but it's should still be part of the album :/

Everybody else likes em, but not me - I guess Oh Daddy?

Much better peformed live - Gold Dust Woman

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? Hypothetically speaking, yes. But in reality, no, I think that the fact that it got cut Rumours added something to it's allure and everything panned out okay in the end..

Overall least favorite - Oh Daddy by far.

[MacShadowsBall]

Glad to see such a great response here on the Rumours forum...;)


Sick to death of - tied between Go Your Own Way / The Chain :eek:

The forgotten about little song that could - probably Oh Daddy, perhaps Second Hand News

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Songbird / Gold Dust Woman; doesn't fit my vision of what Rumours is about

Everybody else likes em, but not me - I realize now that this question is very similiar to the first one... :shrug:

Much better peformed live - The Chain; since Christine is more prominate than on the album version.

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? No; too sappy and "bouncy" sounding


Overall least favorite - Never Going Back Again :nod:

I see Rumours as an fun and uptempo album about the turmoil of relationships and the angst and heartbreak of those relationships.

[GoldDustOrphan]

Sick to death of - "Don't Stop ", Hasn't aged well at all. Has the feel of jingle.

The forgotten about little song that could - Oh Daddy. Christine's voice has some room to breathe, and I love it.

Doesn't belong on Rumours - I Don't Want to Know. Merseybeat sounds out of place. Stevie had better songs in the can.

Everybody else likes em, but not me - "Songbird" I don't dislike, just indifferent

Much better performed live - The Chain (Was such a great opener during Mirage; Stevie and Lindsey's heightened viocals upping the romantic tension.

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? No, because it was the tentpole that supported The Dance, and Stevie's riveting coda was the emotional core.

Overall least favorite - Don't Stop.

[caroline79]

Much better performed live - The Chain (Was such a great opener during Mirage; Stevie and Lindsey's heightened viocals upping the romantic tension.




Completely agree! One of my favorite performances! :thumbsup:

[MacShadowsBall]

Ledgies - PM me your predictions for the Rumours album.

Least Fav Christine
Least Fav Lindsey
Least Fav Stevie
Least Fav song from Rumours

[Conga]

Sick to death of - Go Your Own Way

Even though I'm not really. It just plays at the store I work at every day but I'm too busy to hear it. Don't Stop plays every day. And Everywhere, but that's Tango. Also at my friends' favourite restaurant/hangout Dreams plays everytime we are there, but that's one of the best pop songs of the 70s.

The Forgotten little song that could - Songbird

Not forgotten at all, but amongst the juggernauts, it's maybe too somber for the Lindsey/Stevie fans to remember

Doesn't belong on Rumours - I Don't Want to Know

Silver Springs all the way

Everyone else likes em but not me - N/A

Much better performed live - The Chain, even though it's my fav on Rumours haha

Should Silver Springs been on the Rumours album - Got that right!

Overall least favourite - Oh Daddy

[YoungAmericans]

Sick to death of - Oh Daddy. I wouldn't say I'm sick to death of it. I really like it, but not as much as the others.

The forgotten about little song that could - probably I Don't Want to Know. I totally agree that it saves the album. If it wasn't there, it would be too much of a slow ending. It's a great little bouncy song.

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Oh Daddy... I just think it's lacking something that the others have. My least favourite Chris song with FM.

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Oh Daddy, I guess.

Much better peformed live - none. I like them all how they are on the album and live.

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? I think it should of replaced Oh Daddy, because I think it's just way better.


Overall least favorite - Oh Daddy.

[David]

Sick to death of - The Chain

The forgotten about little song that could - I Don't Want to Know

Doesn't belong on Rumours - Songbird

Everybody else likes em, but not me - n/a

Much better peformed live - The Chain

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? - Nope. But Nicks could have used an upbeat rocker.

Overall least favorite - Songbird

[Christopher]

Sick to death of - Easy choice. "Don't Stop" - Christine's piano chops can't save this song from being the blandest of bland all these years later.

The forgotten about little song that could - "Second Hand News" - this song is groovy (my Marsha Brady moment:lol:) and features nice BN harmonies. I love that FM have revived this song in concert, but I'm surprised its generally ignored on classic rock stations.

Doesn't belong on Rumours - This ones hard. My 1st instinct is to toss away "Oh Daddy", but ultimately I believe all these songs belong on Rumours.

Everybody else likes em, but not me - "Songbird" or "Oh Daddy" are just Meh to me, don't find myself seeking them out ever. I only play them when I listen to Rumours as a whole, which is a rare occasion these days.

Much better peformed live - "Gold Dust Woman" is more muscular in concert, but I still enjoy the trippy and restrained studio version.

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? Hindsight is 20/20 and with "The Dance" squarely in view - My answer is NO. The Rumours version was a popular enough b-side in its day, and received steady FM radio airplay 77' through mid 80's - so it was far from obscure. This song was more emotionally stunning when it was resurrected for The Dance, and had far more reaching resonance. I also prefer the 97' arrangement over 77's.

Overall least favorite - "Oh Daddy"!

[cliffdweller]

Sick to death of - "Don't Stop"

The forgotten about little song that could - "I Don't Wanna Know"

Doesn't belong on Rumours - "Oh Daddy" - sounds like it should be on Tusk

Everybody else likes em, but not me - "Don't Stop" - the public loves this song, but I think hardcore Mac fans are over it.

Much better peformed live - "The Chain"

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? Yes!


Overall least favorite - "Don't Stop"

[Lucia]

Sick to death of - Don't Stop

The forgotten about little song that could - Oh Daddy

Doesn't belong on Rumours - I Don't Want to Know.Stevie can do much better.

Everybody else likes em, but not me - Don't Stop

Much better peformed live - The Chain

Should "Silver Springs" been on the Rumours album? It was subsequently released so I don't really care.Probably no.

Overall least favorite -Songbird

[ryguy2010]

Sick to death of 2 hand news

Doesn't Belong on Rumours This is by far the 1 that doesn't gel w/ rest of album; Great song though but wish Fireflies took its place

Everybody else likes, Not me Like them all
Much better performed Live Gold Dust Woman

Should Silver Springs have been on the album? No but a wonderful song it is. Besides we already have 'Songbird'
Overall least favorite 2 hand news

The forgotten about little song that could I don't want to know