White Album Survivor Rounds 3 and 4

[Hawkeye]

Here is whats left for Round 3

1. Monday Morning
3. Blue Letter
4. Rhiannon
5. Over my Head
6. Crystal
7. Say You Love Me
8. Landslide
9. World Turning
11. I'm So Afraid

[Hawkeye]

The first 2 rounds were a since but now its so tuff. But I thin I'm going with Landslide this time.

[GateandGarden]

I'm sticking with "I'm So Afraid."

[StevieNicksEO17]

I'm So Afraid.

[CreepingDeath]

World Turning

[skcin]

I'm So Afraid (just isn't as good as the liver versions)

[sodascouts]

Such an incredible song live. Such a sucky song on the White Album.

I'm So Afraid.

[thepoetinmyhear]

World Turning!

[HomerMcvie]

I'm sticking with "I'm So Afraid."
Hilllary, I love your new avatar! We go together like cake and ice cream!

[HomerMcvie]

I'm So Afraid (just isn't as good as the liver versions)
I much prefer the gizzard versions. :sorry: :lol: :xoxo:

[Keith]

is my favorite Lindsey song, so I can't vote it off, yet.

How about (tough since this album is solid) uh.. Blue Letter (the not written by a band member song). It was such a great decision to include it on the album.

[Tusk!]

Goodbye to Crystal.

[shackin'up]

I'm So Afraid (just isn't as good as the liver versions)

Now please people, explain. I don't understand this at all. A lot of people like the '70's live versions of Rhiannon more than the studioversion. But I NEVER hear this argument concerning this song.
You all have the right to vote off what you like, of course, but why using totally inconsistant arguments?

Vote:

RHIANNON

Because the live versions in the seventies were better.

[terrivac]

Blue Letter.

Terri

[GateandGarden]

Hilllary, I love your new avatar! We go together like cake and ice cream!Thanks! :) It's definitely my favorite FM album cover, followed by Bare Trees. :nod:

[msLinds]

I vote to get Rid of "BLUE LETTER".




:wavey: :blob1: :blob2: :] :xoxo: :laugh: :p :nod: ;)

[Mad4stevie]

Over My Head. It's ok, but not as good as the others . . .

I like the live version of this song better with the strong harmonies.

[rezamatic]

I have a feeling we're going to see a lot "I love the live version but not the album version" comments in these next few rounds... I think that can be said for I'm So Afraid, Over My Head, Rhiannon, Landslide and World Turning. So keeping that in mind, I'm going to try and get the ball rolling by voting for LANDSLIDE. I've tried but just can't enjoy the studio cut.

Vote: LANDSLIDE

[TheBlueLamp]

This is already really tough. World Turning to go.

[GypsySorcerer]

"I'm So Afraid."

[HomerMcvie]

Blue Letter.

[ryan8472]

Monday Morning :nod:

[Mari]

Again, Blue Letter.

[AliP]

I'm So Afraid

[Kelly]

World Turning.

I am shocked at all the votes for "I'm So Afraid"...them are some of Liddy B's best lyrics from the old days. :eek:

[face of glass]

"Blue Letter". It's tough, though.

[Serrart]

Blue Letter

Romy

[amber]

Blue Letter?! Geez, that's like, the song I always listen to the most. So, I vote for I'm So Afraid...
"wanna beeeeee - on the road to paradise, I wanna lover who don't get old"

[Serrart]

Blue Letter?! Geez, that's like, the song I always listen to the most. So, I vote for I'm So Afraid...
"wanna beeeeee - on the road to paradise, I wanna lover who don't get old"

I like Blue letter, but I'm voting to save I'm so Afraid, it's in any case a fantastic song, IMO. :nod:

Romy

[Sugar]

Blue Letter

[bretonbanquet]

Blue Letter :)

[golden braid]

This is tough now but I'm going to go with World Turning.

[wondergirl9847]

Over My Head

Dang ya'll ISA haters! :mad:

[amber]

Over My Head

Dang ya'll ISA haters! :mad:
Yo, I'm just trying to save blue letter, y'all.

[GateandGarden]

Yo, I'm just trying to save blue letter, y'all.Yeah, it's probably my favorite track on the CD, too. :nod: At first I didn't get into it but it really grew on me.

[jwd]

Monday Morning for round three and if it's still around for round four, then I'll vote for it again. :shrug: :lol:

[Hippocampus]

Over My Head

[Serendipity]

It's gonna have to be World Turning.

[Hawkeye]

just so you know voting for Round 3 voting will continue until 11 tonight

[ontheEdgeof17]

I'm So Afraid.

:wavey:

[Dark Angel]

I'm So Afraid

[Dreammms]

Blue Letter

:confused:

[Hawkeye]

It was a very close Lindsey song battle but here's what happened.

I'm So Afraid is out with 11 votes
Blue Letter had 10 votes
World Turning had 6 votes
Over My Head had 3 votes
Landslide had 2 votes
Monday Morning had 2 votes
Crystal had 1 vote
Rhiannon had 1 vote

we're left with

1. Monday Morning
3. Blue Letter
4. Rhiannon
5. Over My Head
6. Crystal
7. Say You Love Me
8. Landslide
9. World Turning

[sodascouts]

I'm going to vote World Turning, although I actually want Rhiannon to go, in the hopes that Blue Letter hangs on another round. That song rocks!

So it's World Turning for me.

[amber]

over my head.

[Dark Angel]

World Turning

[skcin]

I much prefer the gizzard versions. :sorry: :lol: :xoxo:

Smart ass. :cool: I caught it hours after I typed it, too lazy to edit.


Now please people, explain. I don't understand this at all. A lot of people like the '70's live versions of Rhiannon more than the studioversion. But I NEVER hear this argument concerning this song.
You all have the right to vote off what you like, of course, but why using totally inconsistant arguments?

Vote:

RHIANNON

Because the live versions in the seventies were better.

Why is it inconsistent? My opinion is that I am moved more by live versions of ISA - the guitar is more emotional to me. I don't know how to put it into words. Rhiannon - the vocal is much more raw live, blows me away, I love it.

Are you saying that I should vote off Rhiannon cuz I like it better live? My answer to that is I prefer album Rhiannon over album ISA. Kay? ;)


That being said, I vote off Blue Letter cuz I prefer it live. :laugh:

JK about the live thing - but I am voting off Blue Letter.

[GypsySorcerer]

I'm not ready for Blue Letter or World Turning to go. So "Monday Morning" it is.

[golden braid]

I'm going with World Turning again.

[ryan8472]

Monday Morning.....cuz' it's better live. ;)

[thepoetinmyhear]

World turning

[face of glass]

"Blue Letter".

[amber]

Wow. People actually like Over My Head better than Wuh-uhld Tuhning. it's warping my fragile little mind!

[GateandGarden]

Eh, "Crystal"

[Kelly]

World Turning...


I guess I will miss a few rounds since I am leaving for Vegas in a few hours. All I know is Crystal better still be around when I get back! : > )

[shackin'up]

Smart ass. :cool: I caught it hours after I typed it, too lazy to edit.




Why is it inconsistent? My opinion is that I am moved more by live versions of ISA - the guitar is more emotional to me. I don't know how to put it into words. Rhiannon - the vocal is much more raw live, blows me away, I love it.

Are you saying that I should vote off Rhiannon cuz I like it better live? My answer to that is I prefer album Rhiannon over album ISA. Kay? ;)


That being said, I vote off Blue Letter cuz I prefer it live. :laugh:

JK about the live thing - but I am voting off Blue Letter.

What I meant is: Why voting off a song because it's better live? The live versions are not on the album, the studioversions are. So I'd say: keep the arguments inside the album. I am ticky about it because that live version argument is used for voting off ISA, and not for f.i. Rhiannon.

I agree that both songs are better live, but that is saying NOTHING about the quality of the studiotracks.

So my vote for RHIANNON was meant as a cynical vote, because I felt that ISA was leaving this round, and I was right. Amazing because it is one of the most excentric and spheric tracks on the album. It deserves better.

so because I was right in the fact that ISA was going in round three for unfair reasons, this is my protestvote again

ROUND 4: RHIANNON, because it's better live. :D

[MirrorInTheSky]

Over My Head 'cause it's over rated.

[GypsySorcerer]

Wow. People actually like Over My Head better than Wuh-uhld Tuhning. it's warping my fragile little mind!

I like them both about equally. "Over My Head" is such a breezy tune; perfect for cruising. :nod: I like Stevie's backing vocals, too. :)

[mondaymornin1]

My vote is for World Turning.

Save Blue Letter and Monday Morning, ya'll!!!!

[Mari]

uh.. did I vote in this round yet? Oh no, that was round 3. Kind of confusing.
Anyway,
Blue Letter.

[ontheEdgeof17]

Blue Letter, please

[rezamatic]

In an attempt to save Blue Letter, I'm voting for Over My Head. I see my attempt to get Landslide some votes has expectedly failed. :shrug:

[msLinds]

I vote to get Rid of "Blue Letter".



:wavey: :laugh: :blob2: :blob1: :] :nod: ;)

[bretonbanquet]

I'll go with World Turning this time - I can't believe ISA has gone, you guys are mad :confused: I agree with shackin' up - stick with the album versions :distress:

[ontheEdgeof17]

I'll go with World Turning this time - I can't believe ISA has gone, you guys are mad :confused: I agree with shackin' up - stick with the album versions :distress:


....And the album version of ISA is not above the remaining songs. That's why it is out. :wavey:

[TheBlueLamp]

World Turning to go

[HomerMcvie]

Blue Letter.

[AliP]

My Vote is for: World Turning

I can't believe so many people dislike Over My Head! That is my fave Chris song ever :)

[Neal]

'Blue Letter' ;)

[Serendipity]

Still having to go with World Turning.

[Hippocampus]

Over My Head again

[Serrart]

I'm voting off Blue letter, World Turning is better, and Over my head even more. :D

Romy

[Keith]

Blue Letter, as I mourn the loss if "I'm So Afraid." I dig the album version.

[bretonbanquet]

....And the album version of ISA is not above the remaining songs. That's why it is out. :wavey:

:( Well I really like it, far more than most of the other songs on there... :distress: Democracy sucks :laugh:

[Sugar]

Blue Letter

[WildInTheWind]

Over My Head

[golddustwoman77]

I'm going with "World Turning."

[CreepingDeath]

World Turning

[Johnny Stew]

I dig the album version of "I'm So Afraid," too. :shrug:

I'm voting off "Blue Letter."

[Hawkeye]

Last time I wasted my vote by going first, so this time I'm going last. Blue Letter is the best song on the album next to Rhiannon (yes the STUDIO version is my favorite song ever :laugh: ) now Landslide sucks compared to its live counterpart so Im with Rezamatic in getting that one off soon.


But my strategic vote is for World Turning (which BTW is MUCH better live, even the SYW version, yeah all you vest haters can kiss my a** :laugh: )

[jwd]

After just a quick glance I think the ones in the lead for getting voted off are Over My Head, World Turning, and Blue Letter. Can't, and won't vote for any of those yet. Monday Morning gets my vote again. :p

[Hawkeye]

You can tell its getting harder the way the votes are beginning to spread out. Here they are:

World Turning is out with 13 votes
Blue Letter has 11 votes
Over Head has 5 votes
Monday Morning has 3 votes
Rhiannon has 1 vote
Crystal has 1 vote