"Say You Will" Song Survivor---Round 1

[greatdarkwing]

Ok...first off, some people do not like these Survivor threads, so please do not post your disapproval....just ignore the thread...


OK, now that we have all had time to soak in the album, lets play Survivor......the polls here only allow for 10 options, so until we reach that number, we will just post which one we want to vote off. So, lets play.......!

Thread stops at 10 PM Wednsday night.

1. Whats the World Coming To
2. Murrow Turning Over In His Grave
3. Illume
4. Thrown Down
5. Miranda
6. Red Rover
7. Say You Will
8. Peacekeeper
9. Come
10. Smile At You
11. Running Through The Garden
12. Silver Girl
13. Steal Your Heart Away
14. Bleed To Love Her
15. Everybody Finds Out
16. Destiny Rules
17. Say Goodbye
18. Goodbye Baby


~Alex

[greatdarkwing]

I vote off "Silver Girl" and I have a feeling I wont be the only one!

~Alex

[markolas]

Yeah, I'm gonna have to vote off "Silver Girl," too.

[Jen77]

:wavey:

Definitely "Silver Girl"~its the only one I sometimes skip...:nod:

Jen

[diamondsnake]

Whats the World.... is so boring and lame! I vote for it to be booted off first!

[SaraRhiannon]

One more for Silver Girl.

[gldstwmn]

"She was a silver girl...":distress:

[iamiona]

I vote for What's the World...I always skip this one...nothing really stands out for me in it...

Iona

[sodascouts]

Goodbye, "Silver Girl" - get lost in your hard-core world, lol.

[DrummerDeanna]

Add another vote to the Silver Girl tally :) It's a pretty weak song considering what Stevie can do...

[GardenStateGirlie]

Peace out, Silver Girl.

[wondergirl9847]

Silver Girl take a hike!! :laugh:

[silversprings8]

Silver Girl...

[Janet]

You should make it a poll, you'd have an easier time...

I will vote off Silver Girl as well.

[David R]

yep silver girl... *should have been replaced by "not make believe" on the album but OH WELL... haha*

[darklinensuit]

Red Rover

[sparky]

SG SG SG

[Merf]

"Silver Girl"

Sorry, Mama.

[The Tower]

Say goodbye to

RED ROVER

[macmar71]

And let me continue the riot......

RED ROVER

[TwoTricky]

Didn't like Silver Girl at all...sorry.

[DownOnRodeo]

Originally posted by sodascouts
Goodbye, "Silver Girl" - get lost in your hard-core world, lol. LMAO Nancy :laugh:


<i> It was a dozy song,
To vote it off won't take long.
It was a sappy song,
Immersed amongst likeable ones.
We would have preffered
Not Make Believe.
But that's all right...
It's on it's way. </i>

Ciao SG :wavey:

[ryan8472]

Yet another Silver Girl...

[MacFan03]

Wow, how can anyone want "Red Rover" off????

MY VOTE IS "SILVER GIRL"....see ya.

[kdemelli]

Silver girl has got to go.

Kate

[cliffdweller]

Silver Girl-- snooze, yawn, BORING!

[WednesdaysChild]

Sail on Silver Girl...right off of Say You Will...hahahaha

I really hate that song.

[goldustboi]

I initially felt like a sinner for having this POV but now I know other people are voting RED ROVER off I dont feel as bad - so get rid!!
:nod:

[chiliD]

"Silver Girl".

[wondergirl9847]

OH THE HORROR!!! How can one not love this song? :(

I'm kidding you guys, it's interesting how one song can touch someone's life while others hate/don't like it.

[darklinensuit]

Originally posted by wondergirl9847
OH THE HORROR!!! How can one not love this song? :(


Hmmm, let me THINK ABOUT IT.:laugh:

- Jake

[dissention]

"Bleed to Love Her"

:D

[joe68]

Hmmm, defintely between "Come", "Red Rover", "Murrow" or the muck that became "Smile at You" once Lindsey destroyed it...

Hmmm,
Ok...
"Red Rover" Oye!

At least Lindsey kept his paws off of "Destiny Rules". Wonder what "Silver Girl" would have been in John Shanks hands...?!

[SmthngOfADreamr]

Not that it needs any help in getting voted off, but chalk another up for "silver girl"

[wondergirl9847]

Originally posted by darklinensuit
Hmmm, let me THINK ABOUT IT.:laugh:

- Jake

BWAH!!! Good one!! :laugh:

[Mad4stevie]

Silver Girl - blech.

Although, Red Rover is a close second.

[laurarox]

I love SG. You guys are big goobers!:sorry:

[seteca]

Although after many listens now it isn't AS bad as I originally thought it was...the obvious choice is...

Silver Girl.

:wavey: :wavey: :wavey:

[Jason T.]

How can anyone hate "Silver Girl," I cannot even believe the massive hate towards the song. Anyway I vote that "Bleed To Love Her" to be voted off. It's almost as if they just stuck on a proven hit to sell an album. It makes me feel as if we were cheated out of a song. Now they should of stuck "Not Make Believe" in BTLH's place.

[~nightbird~]

Well, it would be real easy to go along with the majority here and say "Silver Girl" but honestly, I'd have to cast my vote for
"Running Through The Garden". To me, RTTG sounds like it belongs on a Stevie Nicks solo album not on a Fleetwood Mac album.

[EnchantedStorms]

Illume. Really, I can't get through the whole song without jumping up to press the little forward arrow key on the cd player, lol.


~Angela~

[David R]

My sig and I don't like all you "Red Rover" haters...:D

[DownOnRodeo]

Originally posted by wondergirl9847
OH THE HORROR!!! How can one not love this song? :(

I'm kidding you guys, it's interesting how one song can touch someone's life while others hate/don't like it.
I'm waiting for someone to say Silver Girl has changed their life :laugh:
(and not for the worse! ;) )
Nah it's not that bad.

[wondergirl9847]

I agree with seteca in that it's not AS bad as originally thought, but it's mostly the lyrics I don't like...the music is alright (not terrific, just alright). I think the melody is okay, maybe needs a little kick in the rear a bit, more uptempo. I'm looking at this poll as "What's the WEAKEST song on the album?" That would be SG, IMO. :shrug:

[madformac]

I have to agree.

Silver Girl is the weakest track on the album IMO. It's not really that bad at all, it just doesn't sit well on this particular record. It's slow tempo is more suited to Trouble In Shangri-La I feel.

If you ask me, it went on the wrong album. :nod:




:wavey:

[stevierocks87]

Originally posted by DownOnRodeo
LMAO Nancy :laugh:


<i> It was a dozy song,
To vote it off won't take long.
It was a sappy song,
Immersed amongst likeable ones.
We would have preffered
Not Make Believe.
But that's all right...
It's on it's way. </i>

Ciao SG :wavey:

LMAO!!! That was great! Anyway, I agree that Silver Girl isn't as bad as we thought it was at first. I like the chorus (I think i can hear Sheryl pretty well...) and the last part where she sings it a little differently. Not crazy about the music...I feel like I'm boarding a spaceship or something :D

For me, the first ones to go are "Murrow","Red Rover","Silver Girl",and "BTLH". Why on earth did they put that song on the record when they already did it on The Dance? They certainly didn't improve it any, I like The Dance version much better.

So, I'm going to say "BTLH". Atleast Silver Girl is new.

:wavey: adam :wavey:

[iamstevienicks]

It has to be the incredibly lame SILVER GIRL

[Wayne2]

Silver Girl


next round you should try using a poll

[greatdarkwing]

The problem is that the polls only allow for 10 options to be listed. Until I reach that number, I can not do this as a poll.

~Alex

[WindingRoad]

Bleed to Love Her.

I still don't know why Lindsey put it on SYW. I like the song, just doesn't belong on a new release.

susieq :wavey:

[Wayne2]

Originally posted by greatdarkwing
The problem is that the polls only allow for 10 options to be listed. Until I reach that number, I can not do this as a poll.

~Alex

oh ok

carry on:D

[greatdarkwing]

24 Hours until the thread closes and Round 2 begins!

~Alex

[macmar71]

Alex~~~
Can't wait for the second round to begin. Looking forward to seeing the next round of vote offs. I already have the song in mind for next time but will save posting it until the next round appears.

[Sarah]

Silver. Girl.

I.Hate.This.Song.

[darklinensuit]

Originally posted by DownOnRodeo
LMAO Nancy :laugh:


<i> It was a dozy song,
To vote it off won't take long.
It was a sappy song,
Immersed amongst likeable ones.
We would have preffered
Not Make Believe.
But that's all right...
It's on it's way. </i>

Ciao SG :wavey:

Cool, another song parody. One good turn deserves another.

Why do you drone about Greek gods coming down to earth
You know it just brings me down
It's something I must skip
This song doesn't belong here, I guess it never did
Even holler Family Man in my ear just to keep it so well hid
Anyone at all will find any melody missing
Could hear the enthusiasm dying while the folks at Warner Brothers were sighing
Because Anne Heche's lips you were kissing night after night
Her mother ships were bathed in blue, her gods all bathed in white
Red rover red rover red rover
Anne didn't come didn't come didn't come and now it's over

One of the weak Say You Will songs, one of the few
Now fetch me my ear plugs, is this the best you can do
I bought this album knowing that you usually write well
And there's no more annoying song in heaven or hell
Red rover red rover red rover
I'm waiting I'm waiting I'm waiting for your monotonous chorus to be over

Silver Girl needs a pet. Please send her the red dog on the next vote!
:wavey:

[Wayne2]

Originally posted by darklinensuit
Cool, another song parody. One good turn deserves another.

Why do you drone about Greek gods coming down to earth
You know it just brings me down
It's something I must skip
This song doesn't belong here, I guess it never did
Even holler Family Man in my ear just to keep it so well hid
Anyone at all will find any melody missing
Could hear the enthusiasm dying while the folks at Warner Brothers were sighing
Because Anne Heche's lips you were kissing night after night
Her mother ships were bathed in blue, her gods all bathed in white
Red rover red rover red rover
Anne didn't come didn't come didn't come and now it's over

One of the weak Say You Will songs, one of the few
Now fetch me my ear plugs, is this the best you can do
I bought this album knowing that you usually write well
And there's no more annoying song in heaven or hell
Red rover red rover red rover
I'm waiting I'm waiting I'm waiting for your monotonous chorus to be over

Silver Girl needs a pet. Please send her the red dog on the next vote!
:wavey:

Red Rover is (arguably) the best written song on the album. IMO

[DeeGeMe]

I sorta like Silver Girl. Let's put it this way, I like it more than I like Running Through the Garden. That being said, Red Rover has to rove on out of here. It must GO!

[HejiraNYC]

A megamix of "Silver Girl" and "I Miss You" would be an effective cure for insomnia. Silver Girl, you have a million bucks, so buy a one-way ticket to Siberia!

[blinker12]

I'd like to vote off "COME."

[blackdove]

Silver *yawn* girl

[greatdarkwing]

This poll is now closed!

~Alex

[WednesdaysChild]

So how does this work? Who got voted off--the one with the most "comments"? What happens now?

[WednesdaysChild]

Never mind. I saw the Round 2 thread.