American Idol: Top 12

[JazmenFlowers]

Originally Posted by BTFLCHLD

then again im not a dentist

that was hilarious when I read it...lol...I'm still laughing

[cliffdweller]

I'm afraid last night was Bucky's last performance. He's so gone.

I am so SICK of Lisa. Ugh She is so boring and forgettable.

I agree with you Jannie, Kevin thinks he's getting voted through because he's good and that's just a shame. Actually, that's what pisses me off the most about that guy and it's not even his fault!

Pickler: meh

Paris: meh

Katherine: I can't believe Simon liked her performance as much as he did! I thought it was boring, but she has a beautiful voice and she's gorgeous so...

Ace: Nice try pulling that falsetto out of your ass at the end, but no dice k?

Elliott: His attempt at vibratto was hilarious. He's a good singer overall though.

Taylor: Weak vocal, he's coasting on personality at this point.

I kinda liked Chris's Walk The Line last night. Now THAT I could see him recording, not that Chili Peppers knock off.

Mandisa kicks ass!! Oh please, oh please I hope she wins!

[DavidMn]

Originally Posted by JazmenFlowers

that was hilarious when I read it...lol...I'm still laughing

That's my Elliot!

[BTFLCHLD]

Originally Posted by JazmenFlowers

...lol...

[Sorceress]

Originally Posted by JazmenFlowers

I agree...it was a much better week. I didn't notice Elliott's teeth. I need to find a pic cause brother needed some serious help.

my picks in order:

Mandisa - flawless
Chris - amazing
Paris - hot
Kellie - I thought she worked it out
Elliott - a little off here and there, but still a great performance
Katharine - she should bitch slap whoever dressed her; song was boring
Ace - I almost couldn't listen to the first half; he needs to get, dare I say, more confident
Taylor - yuck
Kevin - bless it
Bucky - I swear I didn't even know what the hell he was singing
Lisa - bad song choice, bad outfit, bad, bad, bad

Yes, Katharine's outfit was terribly unflattering. She's such a cute girl that it should NOT be hard to dress her. What's wrong with them?

Mandisa, Chris and Paris were great.

I hate Kellie no matter what. Her song choice was a good one, but compared to Patsy's version, she just didn't cut it.

Ace is just not as talented as he should be. I really am hating his falsetto. He looks much better when he's smiling instead of trying to look sexy.

I still love Taylor, but his song was terribly boring.

Elliot! He looked SO much better last night, from the teeth to the outfit to the facial hair. Thank you to his stylist. Maybe that person can help Katharine out too.

Kevin, Bucky or Lisa need to go tonight. Lisa is trying so hard but she is just not natural enough. Poor Bucky just can't really sing, though he does have a nice personality. And Kevin? Little Kevin? He needs to wait a few years--until he is shaving, at least. And that would give him some time to work with a speech therapist on that lisp.

[JazmenFlowers]

Originally Posted by Sorceress

that lisp.

and it's a crooked lisp. even worse!

I agree with all you said...except that I don't hate Kellie as much as some others.

[wondergirl9847]

Gah. I am so bored with these people. I don't like being yelled at by Mandisa, I don't like hearing Ace being murdered (he IS being murdered, right? ), I don't like being put to sleep by Lisa, I don't like hearing Pickle push women back about 80 years.

I'm only watching to read the snark the next day.

[DavidMn]

Originally Posted by wondergirl9847

Gah. I am so bored with these people. I don't like being yelled at by Mandisa, I don't like hearing Ace being murdered (he IS being murdered, right? ), I don't like being put to sleep by Lisa, I don't like hearing Pickle push women back about 80 years.

I'm only watching to read the snark the next day.

I think I'll start calling Kellie miss Claussen.

[skcin]

Originally Posted by ontheEdgeof17

A MUCH better week. The song choiced were good and the vocals were 10 times better. Here's my breakdown, with Bucky to go home.



Kicked Ass:

Mandisa
Chris
Pickler
Katherine

Kicked Butt:

Elliott (THEY FIXED HIS TEETH! )
Paris
Ace
Taylor


Kicked the Can:

Kevin
Bucky
Lisa

See, THIS? Is why you're my soulmate. I agree with you, although I think Lisa might go instead of Bucky.

[Brwn_eyes0511]

Katharine was the best.

And she did a smashing version of one of my favs. "Come Rain or Come Shine"

[SapphireSister]

-Bucky just needs to go. Is he even singing? What is that called?

-I loved Lisa at the beginning but now she's gone down. I still think she should make it a bit further though.

-I just don't understand what the huge deal is about Elliot. He can sing but his voice isn't anything special to me. He's boring to watch and I'm sorry but he's horrible to look at (those ears OMG). I know the show shouldn't be based on looks but I don't want to look at him.

-I hate to say it but Pickler sounded great.

-Taylor is nothing special and his shtick does not entertain me.

-Chris is great but unoriginal. His voice sounds like the lead singer of 10 bands out there right now that all sound alike i.e. Nickleback, 3 Doors Down, Creed, etc. and we don't need another one.

-Paris is too perky and dances too much. She just annoys me although she is very talented. She's overly confident.

-Kevin is there because they think he's cute but he will not win.

-Ace is there because of looks, he won't last and that stare at the end of his songs, I want to shoot him.

-Regardless of who wins KATHERINE IS MY AMERICAN IDOL *swoon*. She has the looks, talent, and personality. She's the total package in my book. I really want her to win. I adore the crap out of her.

[jannieC]

Originally Posted by SapphireSister

-Paris is too perky and dances too much. She just annoys me although she is very talented. She's overly confident.

And did anyone notice that when asked how Barry Mannilow helped her, she couldn't say one thing about him? I think she's a little overly confident, too.

And speaking of Barry, I thought he was so cool!

[Livia]

Barry rocks my world. Yeah, I said it! He's a great arranger!

Katherine hit a major clunker note toward the end and no one said anything! I heard it from the next room, it was so obvious. I love her, but it's clear that the judges love her too...makes me think they really are being coached by the producers...

Chicken Little, oy....be gone, lispy boy (baby talk, baby talk, it's a wonder he can walk....)!

I agree with Curtis' choices as well..and I'm really ready for Taylor to be gone...but I think it will be Bucky.

[skcin]

Originally Posted by SapphireSister

-

-Regardless of who wins KATHERINE IS MY AMERICAN IDOL *swoon*. She has the looks, talent, and personality. She's the total package in my book. I really want her to win. I adore the crap out of her.

That girl is so naturally beautiful it's amazing. That skin, those cheekbones, that hair. Gorgeous.

[SapphireSister]

Originally Posted by skcin

That girl is so naturally beautiful it's amazing. That skin, those cheekbones, that hair. Gorgeous.

OMG she's beautiful! My mom thinks she looks like Katherine Zeta-Jones (maybe a little). What I also love about her is that she's not stick thin and still has an incredible figure! A great role model for young girls.