Part 2; Tusk Song Survivor - Page 11

CarneVaca · #**151** 08-26-2004, 11:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hawkeye

OK I'll delete my SMAP vote. And hopefully TISL will delete their WMYTYTO vote.

And unfortunutly screaming Jakes name won't get his attentiopn if he's not here

OK, well, we need an official ruling from him. Cuz as I see it, you just gave immunity to a song that got voted off.

Hawkeye · #**152** 08-26-2004, 11:03 PM

A) I seriously believe BC is NOT gone, the previous votes come from ALL previous rounds. Go look at the RE-DO of Tusk Song Survivor and find out for yourself.

B) IF and it's a big IF., BC is in fact gone, I should still get to choose what gets immunity, if not BC then something else

xdreamsunwindx · #**153** 08-26-2004, 11:04 PM

I swear if there ends up being yet ANOTHER thread regarding the Tusk Song Survivor, I am leaving until it's finished. This is getting REDICULOUS.

-Kate

CarneVaca · #**154** 08-26-2004, 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hawkeye

A) I seriously believe BC is NOT gone, the previous votes come from ALL previous rounds. Go look at the RE-DO of Tusk Song Survivor and find out for yourself.

Well, you are quite mistaken on this.

Quote:

B) IF and it's a big IF., BC is in fact gone, I should still get to choose what gets immunity, if not BC then something else

I don't dispute that. You should get to choose immunity; you answered the question first. So pick a song that is actually in play and we can move forward.

Anyway, it's late. I'm off to bed.

CarneVaca · #**155** 08-26-2004, 11:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xdreamsunwindx

I swear if there ends up being yet ANOTHER thread regarding the Tusk Song Survivor, I am leaving until it's finished. This is getting REDICULOUS.

-Kate

Would you have us ignore the fact that Jacob miscounted, and as a result the whole thing is once again in disarray? I know it's inconvenient, but shouldn't we set it straight?

Otherwise, we're no better than Florida here.

Hawkeye · #**156** 08-26-2004, 11:12 PM

WELL I Know why Jake miscounted. I counted the same thing as him actually with BC having 13 and TEFM having 14. Serrat voted TWICE. I kept going over and over and kept getting 14, becasue it's not obvious at all that Serrat voted twice. I don't even know if they knew they did, but they did.

AND if Jake counted the last vote after 9 PM it'd be back up to 14. AND 77Rumours themselves didn't vote so maybe he casted a silent vote.

And I'm not going to choose another song unless Jake makes a ruling. I say we just halt the game until he does.

jwd · #**157** 08-26-2004, 11:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 77Rumours77

Now Sara and SAVE both had 13. Now the tie breaker is to see who has had more votes in the past rounds Sara had 9 and SAVE had 4. So this means Sara is offically gone
I am delaying "tribal counsel" till later tonight so I can figure out the votes for this round. Sorry about the confusion

In his own words. And notice he uses the word in the plural sense, rounds. That's how it's always been done on Survivor. So every vote, in every round counts for a song, in case of a tie.

See ya TEFM!

My vote this round goes to SMAP! FLUSH!

HomerMcvie · #**158** 08-26-2004, 11:21 PM

Quote:

Exactly. Based on the previous round, Beutiful Child is GONE.

Hawkeye · #**159** 08-26-2004, 11:25 PM

don't celebrate too soon Mr. McVie. It's very very clear now, thanks to JWD that TEFM is GONE, Beautiful Child is actually still in survivor and has IMMUNITY

HomerMcvie · #**160** 08-26-2004, 11:35 PM

Quote:

don't celebrate too soon Mr. McVie. It's very very clear now, thanks to JWD that TEFM is GONE, Beautiful Child is actually still in survivor and has IMMUNITY

DOH! Too late to call off the celebration.

Where's Jacob when we need a judgement call?
Regardless fo the outcome, I have the comfort of knowing that Beautiful Child blows goats.

Johnny Stew · #**161** 08-26-2004, 11:38 PM

Wow, yet another instance when a Lindsey song gets booted, and the results are immediately called into question. Recounts are demanded. Rule verification is required. Soon we'll have to start a FOURTH new thread for the same album.

Is there something wrong with my monitor, or am I seeing a pattern here?

If anyone ever wondered what it would be like if the Three Stooges competed on Survivor, just look at this thread!