Fleetwood Mac Album Survivor Game

[shackin'up]

Then Play On 13+
Mystery To Me 21-
Rumours 55
Tusk 87
Mirage 29

[Hippocampus]

Then Play On 12 -
Mystery To Me 21
Rumours 55
Tusk 88 +
Mirage 29

[shackin'up]

Then Play On 13+
Mystery To Me 20-
Rumours 55
Tusk 88
Mirage 29

[Sarah]

Then Play On 13
Mystery To Me 20
Rumours 54 -
Tusk 89 +
Mirage 29


edited

[shackin'up]

edit sarah

[TheWILDheart]

Then Play On 12 -
Mystery To Me 20
Rumours 56 +
Tusk 88
Mirage 27

I don't like TPO or MTM. Rumours is the strongest album the mac ever made. Tusk is, indeed, amazing but for me Rumours is that little bit better. Stevie's songs on Tusk are pretty amazing though

[shackin'up]

Originally Posted by Sarah

Then Play On. I have it. I like it. But in my opinion, it's Tusk's strongest opposition, and I really want Tusk to win it all.

Me too, dear, but I think it would have been great if those two were spared for the final.
The two strongest albums by the two strongest incarnations of FM.

[Sarah]

Originally Posted by shackin'up

Me too, dear, but I think it would have been great if those two were spared for the final.
The two strongest albums by the two strongest incarnations of FM.

if this was more of a popular voting situation, i'd agree. but it's come down to which side has the most time to sit and vote over and over. i don't have much computer time, so i'm trying to keep an objective.

WILD's last vote needs to be corrected since i just had to edit my last one.

[shackin'up]

fair enough....

[shackin'up]

Then Play On 13+
Mystery To Me 19-
Rumours 55
Tusk 89
Mirage 29

corrected

[Sarah]

Then Play On 13
Mystery To Me 19
Rumours 54 -
Tusk 90 +
Mirage 29

[shackin'up]

Then Play On 14+
Mystery To Me 18-
Rumours 54
Tusk 90
Mirage 29

[chiliD]

Then Play On 14
Mystery To Me 19+
Rumours 53-
Tusk 90
Mirage 29

There's not a Fleetwood Mac album I don't like...I just like some better than others.

MTM is just as strong as anything FMac ever did up to that point. Had they been able to finish the tour, I'd bet it would've been their "breakthrough" album like the "white album" eventually was.

In a perfect world, the "Final Four" SHOULD be TPO, MTM, Rumours & Tusk. Those are their "Top 4" strongest albums musically.
I know..."Shut up & vote".

[Sarah]

Then Play On 14 (corrected)
Mystery To Me 19 (corrected)
Rumours 53 (corrected)
Tusk 90 (corrected)
Mirage 29


my votes:
Then Play On 14
Mystery To Me 19
Rumours 52 -
Tusk 91 +
Mirage 29


i have to say that i agree with you on MTM, chili. i think there were a couple times i voted + on white album, - on MTM, and kind of felt bad about it. it is a very, very good record.. in my opinion.. above TPO - which I also like very much.

[TheWILDheart]

Well I am totally biased as I'm a complete chiffon head. So my top 4 would be:

Rumours
Tusk
Mirage
Say You Will

however, seeing as it's not:

Then Play On 13 -
Mystery To Me 19
Rumours 53
Tusk 90
Mirage 30 +