Would Peter do it?

DavidMn · #1 12-07-2005, 12:13 PM

I'm very facinated by the thought of Peter Green joining Fleetwood Mac onstage for their next tour, although I'm not sure that will happen. I guess my question would be, wold Peter be willing to do it, or would Lindsey be willing to share the stage with him. I certainly hope he would, since there would not have been a Fleetwood Mac to begin with if it werent for the Green god.

SteveMacD · #2 12-07-2005, 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DavidMn

I'm very facinated by the thought of Peter Green joining Fleetwood Mac onstage for their next tour, although I'm not sure that will happen. I guess my question would be, wold Peter be willing to do it, or would Lindsey be willing to share the stage with him. I certainly hope he would, since there would not have been a Fleetwood Mac to begin with if it werent for the Green god.

I doubt that he would, though it would be fun. Lindsey would certainly be open to it, though. I think Green is really the only Mac guitarist that he would want to share the stage with. Lindsey's ALWAYS had glowing thing to say about Peter Green. I think it would be cool for Stevie to do the old "Rhiannon" dance during the solo of "Black Magic Woman." Make the song a conceptual piece.

DavidMn · #3 12-07-2005, 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

I doubt that he would, though it would be fun. Lindsey would certainly be open to it, though. I think Green is really the only Mac guitarist that he would want to share the stage with. Lindsey's ALWAYS had glowing thing to say about Peter Green. I think it would be cool for Stevie to do the old "Rhiannon" dance during the solo of "Black Magic Woman." Make the song a conceptual piece.

I like that. Very fresh thinking.

Jyqm · #4 12-07-2005, 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DavidMn

I'm very facinated by the thought of Peter Green joining Fleetwood Mac onstage for their next tour, although I'm not sure that will happen. I guess my question would be, wold Peter be willing to do it, or would Lindsey be willing to share the stage with him. I certainly hope he would, since there would not have been a Fleetwood Mac to begin with if it werent for the Green god.

Gotta say, I don't care for this idea at all. I like Peter, I like Lindsey/Stevie, but I don't really have any desire to see them share the same stage. I think it would end up coming across as some kind of pity gesture, and most of the folks in the audience who came to see Lindsey/Stevie would have no idea who the guy was, nor care to hear any of his songs, and that would just be incredibly unfair to Peter.* I don't think Peter would come across very well with such a huge pop backing band, either. It would just be two completely contrary aesthetics working against each other.

*While I fully believe that Fleetwood Mac underestimates their audience in a big way and really ought to "challenge" them more by playing more relatively obscure material and mixing things up a bit, I do think bringing Peter out on stage would be pushing it a bit too far.

DavidMn · #5 12-07-2005, 12:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jyqm

Gotta say, I don't care for this idea at all. I like Peter, I like Lindsey/Stevie, but I don't really have any desire to see them share the same stage. I think it would end up coming across as some kind of pity gesture, and most of the folks in the audience who came to see Lindsey/Stevie would have no idea who the guy was, nor care to hear any of his songs, and that would just be incredibly unfair to Peter.* I don't think Peter would come across very well with such a huge pop backing band, either. It would just be two completely contrary aesthetics working against each other.

*While I fully believe that Fleetwood Mac underestimates their audience in a big way and really ought to "challenge" them more by playing more relatively obscure material and mixing things up a bit, I do think bringing Peter out on stage would be pushing it a bit too far.

Well, I respect that opinion, but if they would do it, I would hope that it would be handled in a way that could make it possible. Maybe you're right though..

Jyqm · #6 12-07-2005, 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DavidMn

Well, I respect that opinion, but if they would do it, I would hope that it would be handled in a way that could make it possible. Maybe you're right though..

I mean, I'm just taking a very realistic and somewhat cynical approach. If Fleetwood Mac existed in a vacuum, and you said, "Hey, wanna go to this Fleetwood Mac concert? Peter Green is going to be playing along with Lindsey, Stevie, John and Mick, and there's only enough tickets for the hardcore fans," I'd be there in a second.

Unfortunately, that ain't gonna happen. The two realities that really turn me off to the idea are 1) the audience (I mean, if half the venue takes a piss break when Lindsey plays "Come," can you imagine what would happen if Pete shuffled on stage and the band went into "Albatross"?) and 2) the fact that Fleetwood Mac on tour is not just Fleetwood Mac (apologies to Brett and Taku and the rest, but I just don't see them meshing very well with Mr. Green).

DavidMn · #7 12-07-2005, 01:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jyqm

I mean, I'm just taking a very realistic and somewhat cynical approach. If Fleetwood Mac existed in a vacuum, and you said, "Hey, wanna go to this Fleetwood Mac concert? Peter Green is going to be playing along with Lindsey, Stevie, John and Mick, and there's only enough tickets for the hardcore fans," I'd be there in a second.

Unfortunately, that ain't gonna happen. The two realities that really turn me off to the idea are 1) the audience (I mean, if half the venue takes a piss break when Lindsey plays "Come," can you imagine what would happen if Pete shuffled on stage and the band went into "Albatross"?) and 2) the fact that Fleetwood Mac on tour is not just Fleetwood Mac (apologies to Brett and Taku and the rest, but I just don't see them meshing very well with Mr. Green).

Ok, I HAVE to share this with you. On SYW, Albatross would play at the end of every show, and one night this guy came up to me and said WTF is that they're playing? It sounds like elevator music. I wanted to give this turkey a piece of my mind I tell ya....

SteveMacD · #8 12-07-2005, 01:20 PM

I have to say that this debate only applies to North America. I think "Oh Well" and "Black Magic Woman" would be the only songs the North American crowds would get into, and maybe "Manalishi" and "Rattlesnake," though I'm not as certain. I think the band worked for so many years to get out of Green's shadow and succeeded that it wouldn't work too well.

Now, Europe is another story. I think it would be absolutely huge there.

David · #9 12-07-2005, 01:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jyqm

I don't think Peter would come across very well with such a huge pop backing band, either. It would just be two completely contrary aesthetics working against each other.

Absolutely right. All that hardware & all those meddling backeruppers would bury anybody guesting. Heck, they bury the guys already in the band. The whole Fleetwood Mac show is a circus these days. What does that have to do with Peter Green? And why would Peter's fans want to hear him trying to play above three corny girl backup singers, four or five other guitarists, a percussionist & fifty different synthesizer modules, all going at full throttle?

You might as well put Christine onstage with Rage Against the Machine.

HomerMcvie · #10 12-07-2005, 01:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David

You might as well put Christine onstage with Rage Against the Machine.

Now THAT, I'd pay to see.

They SYW Orchestra? No thanks.

Brwn_eyes0511 · #11 12-07-2005, 02:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David

Absolutely right. All that hardware & all those meddling backeruppers would bury anybody guesting. Heck, they bury the guys already in the band. The whole Fleetwood Mac show is a circus these days. What does that have to do with Peter Green? And why would Peter's fans want to hear him trying to play above three corny girl backup singers, four or five other guitarists, a percussionist & fifty different synthesizer modules, all going at full throttle?

You might as well put Christine onstage with Rage Against the Machine.

That is like the best thing I have read all day...

chiliD · #12 12-07-2005, 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David

And why would Peter's fans want to hear him...

...play any venue that holds more than 3,000 people.

unless it was a daytime, outdoor gig in summer, on a football field at a college campus somewhere near the Pacific Ocean