Agree or disagree

MissLadyLoki · #1 05-28-2010, 09:10 AM

I've played this little game in my Metallica and Led Zeppelin groups on Facebook and I thought I'd bring it to here. Basically, someone makes a statement about the band at hand, the next person say whether or not they agree with it, and then post a new statement. Here's an example:

Person A: John Bonham is a way better drummer than Phil Collins

Person B: Agree
Fade to Black is the best song on Ride the Lightning

And so on. I'll start us off.

Fleetwood Mac sounds better live than in the studio

Sleepless-Child · #2 05-28-2010, 09:38 AM

And what if you just can't answer that? ha.

london · #3 05-28-2010, 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MissLadyLoki

I've played this little game in my Metallica and Led Zeppelin groups on Facebook and I thought I'd bring it to here. Basically, someone makes a statement about the band at hand, the next person say whether or not they agree with it, and then post a new statement. Here's an example:

Person A: John Bonham is a way better drummer than Phil Collins

Person B: Agree
Fade to Black is the best song on Ride the Lightning

And so on. I'll start us off.

Fleetwood Mac sounds better live than in the studio

Hi MissLadyLoki,

Ooh, that's not an easy question for me to answer, but...I'll go with I agree. Rhiannon on Fleetwood Mac Live (1980) is my favorite version of the song...when I see FMac in concert and The Chain begins, the adrenalin is unbelievable...and when Lindsey plays ISA in concert, that's magic!

Sleepless-Child · #4 05-28-2010, 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by london

Hi MissLadyLoki,

Ooh, that's not an easy question for me to answer, but...I'll go with I agree. Rhiannon on Fleetwood Mac Live (1980) is my favorite version of the song...when I see FMac in concert and The Chain begins, the adrenalin is unbelievable...and when Lindsey plays ISA in concert, that's magic!

(yeah, your answer's cool

. now you have to do an other statement !)

jaycee · #5 05-28-2010, 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MissLadyLoki

I've played this little game in my Metallica and Led Zeppelin groups on Facebook and I thought I'd bring it to here. Basically, someone makes a statement about the band at hand, the next person say whether or not they agree with it, and then post a new statement. Here's an example:

Person A: John Bonham is a way better drummer than Phil Collins

Person B: Agree
Fade to Black is the best song on Ride the Lightning

And so on. I'll start us off.

Fleetwood Mac sounds better live than in the studio

Disagree (they just sound different, which I love - it'd be less interesting to see a live show where they sounded exactly the same with exactly the same sounding instrumentation).
"You And I, Pt. I" should've been on TITN instead of "You And I, Pt. II".

MissLadyLoki · #6 05-28-2010, 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jaycee

"You And I, Pt. I" should've been on TITN instead of "You And I, Pt. II".

Agree. I always found it a bit strange that there was a Part II on there, and I always figured Part I was on Mirage or something.

The Rosebud version is the best version of Rhiannon around.

Sleepless-Child · #7 05-28-2010, 09:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MissLadyLoki

Agree. I always found it a bit strange that there was a Part II on there, and I always figured Part I was on Mirage or something.

The Rosebud version is the best version of Rhiannon around.

Yay ! I agree (even if I like the Midnight Special one, but it's similar...)

"Don't stop" is overrated.

MissLadyLoki · #8 05-28-2010, 09:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sleepless-Child

Yay ! I agree (even if I like the Midnight Special one, but it's similar...)

"Don't stop" is overrated.

Disagree. I love that song to pieces, but I personally find Dreams to be grossely overrated.

The best part of The Chain is John's bass part

london · #9 05-28-2010, 09:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MissLadyLoki

Disagree. I love that song to pieces, but I personally find Dreams to be grossely overrated.

The best part of The Chain is John's bass part

Agree!

Gypsy live doesn't match the magic on the recording.

chriskisn · #10 05-28-2010, 09:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MissLadyLoki

Disagree. I love that song to pieces, but I personally find Dreams to be grossely overrated.

The best part of The Chain is John's bass part

Agree

Stevie Nicks can not manage to keep in time during a live duet

ButterCookie · #11 05-28-2010, 09:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MissLadyLoki

Disagree. I love that song to pieces, but I personally find Dreams to be grossely overrated.

The best part of The Chain is John's bass part

Disagree about Don't Stop being overrated.

Agree about John's bass part in The Chain

The Dance version of Tusk is the best recording?

Sleepless-Child · #12 05-28-2010, 10:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ButterCookie

Disagree about Don't Stop being overrated.

Agree about John's bass part in The Chain

The Dance version of Tusk is the best recording?

DAMMIT ! Dreams is a great song

Agreed. God, I remember, once, I put the Dance, and my whole family danced to Tusk. It was a great shared Fleetwood Mac moment.

Crystal is better when Lindsey's singing it.

MissLadyLoki · #13 05-28-2010, 10:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sleepless-Child

DAMMIT ! Dreams is a great song

Agreed. God, I remember, once, I put the Dance, and my whole family danced to Tusk. It was a great shared Fleetwood Mac moment.

Crystal is better when Lindsey's singing it.

I'm not gonna lie, I never actually saw The Dance, but I can tell you that, out of all of the Mac's different video footage, the Tusk doc is my fave.

Agree. Stevie is a good singer and all, but it's the kinda song that works best with Lindsey's voice (both Buckingham Nicks and White Album versions).

Christine's best songs are on Tango in the Night (Everywhere, Little Lies, etc.)

ButterCookie · #14 05-28-2010, 10:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MissLadyLoki

I'm not gonna lie, I never actually saw The Dance, but I can tell you that, out of all of the Mac's different video footage, the Tusk doc is my fave.

Agree. Stevie is a good singer and all, but it's the kinda song that works best with Lindsey's voice (both Buckingham Nicks and White Album versions).

Christine's best songs are on Tango in the Night (Everywhere, Little Lies, etc.)

Partly agree, partly disagree. She was on FIRE in 1987 but there's absolute diamonds throughout her entire career.

Neither Stevie or Chris should ever have been allowed near hair crimpers. Or anyone, really.

MissLadyLoki · #15 05-28-2010, 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ButterCookie

Partly agree, partly disagree. She was on FIRE in 1987 but there's absolute diamonds throughout her entire career.

Neither Stevie or Chris should ever have been allowed near hair crimpers. Or anyone, really.

Lol agree. Same goes for Mick and razors.

Of all of Stevie's looks over the years, she looked her best (and absolutely adorable) with that shaggy haircut around the White Album.