Worst Mac-related cover version - Page 3

nicepace · #31 07-30-2009, 06:26 AM

Quote:

I hate the Eva Cassidy version of Songbird. Sorry I don't like it at all.

I agree. I think Eva's version is terrible ... sappy and overproduced.

On the other hand, I LOVE Willie Nelson's version of "Songbird."

chiliD · #32 07-30-2009, 09:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nicepace

I agree. I think Eva's version is terrible ... sappy and overproduced.

On the other hand, I LOVE Willie Nelson's version of "Songbird."

The song itself is "sappy"...that's a given right from the start.

I think Eva's is even better than Christine's...so it just goes to show that everybody's tastes are different.

nicepace · #33 07-30-2009, 05:13 PM

Quote:

The song itself is "sappy"...that's a given right from the start.

I disagree. I think "Songbird" is heartfelt and sincere, not sappy. But as you say, it just shows how tastes (and interpretations) differ.

starshine · #34 07-30-2009, 06:25 PM

I like Eva Cassidy's version of 'Songbird'....I was excited that she'd recorded a song called 'Nightbird' too but its not Stevie's NB...not really sure who's it is.....just some thoughts.....

skuncles · #35 08-04-2009, 12:19 PM

Someone mentioned Wilson Phillip's "Go Your Own Way". What makes their version so cruddy is they took the heart of the song out of it. GYOW is a major F-You song. It supposed to be dripping with venom. That's what makes it so great. You're standing there telling your ex that she was a mistake and I can't help it if I don't love you anymore, just get away and leave me alone. The WP girls took it and turned it around so now it's basically become a "poor pitiful me, go, leave I'm heartbroken" whinefest. It's fine to cover hit songs, but at least understand where the song is coming from and get the feel right!

michelej1 · #36 08-04-2009, 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by skuncles

Someone mentioned Wilson Phillip's "Go Your Own Way". What makes their version so cruddy is they took the heart of the song out of it. GYOW is a major F-You song. It supposed to be dripping with venom. That's what makes it so great. You're standing there telling your ex that she was a mistake and I can't help it if I don't love you anymore, just get away and leave me alone. The WP girls took it and turned it around so now it's basically become a "poor pitiful me, go, leave I'm heartbroken" whinefest. It's fine to cover hit songs, but at least understand where the song is coming from and get the feel right!

If Lindsey had sung the song this way, Stevie probably would have liked it a whole lot better.

I think it's fine to change the meaning of the song, if the new meaning comports with the lyrics. The sing-songy way Wilson Phillips perform the song does not match the lyrics to me.

I always say that what I like about Matchbox Twenty's NGBA is that they sound numb and alienated from love and like they really are never going back. Lindsey's doesn't sound that way. They brought out a meaning in the song that Lindsey's version doesn't fully approach.

Michele

goldustsongbird · #37 08-04-2009, 04:45 PM

Eva Cassidy's Songbird.

Wilson Phillips' GYOW. I heard it in a store awhile ago and my jaw actually dropped.

Bob Welch's take on Rhiannon. It's not *bad*, just different. I'm kind of on the fence about it. His Black Magic Woman is cool.

aleuzzi · #38 08-04-2009, 05:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chriskisn

Pretty much anything on the Patron Saints of Pop album...

Now see I love almost everything on that one!

aleuzzi · #39 08-04-2009, 05:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jedw

how about Rod stewarts "Stand back"? .. sigh, at least that ones mildly amuzing.

OMG, I didn't know he covered that. What a trainwreck it has to be!

PenguinHead · #40 08-04-2009, 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Villavic

I agree. Though I love Elton, this was a big mistake

I LOVE Elton! I LOVE Fleetwood Mac! (and Elton loves Fleetwood Mac), but never should the two have musically met. It's just wrong!

Excalibur881 · #41 08-08-2009, 03:21 AM

Nobody has mentioned Judas Priest's version of 'Green Manalishi'! They've been playing it in every concert since 1978!
I thought there was some great stuff on the 'Peter Green Songbook' CDs. 'Oh Well' by Billy Sheehan was awesome.

nicepace · #42 08-09-2009, 07:02 AM

Quote:

Nobody has mentioned Judas Priest's version of 'Green Manalishi'! They've been playing it in every concert since 1978!

That's because this thread is about BAD cover versions of FM songs. Judas Priest's "Green Manalishi" is a GOOD cover version.