Say You Will: Favorite Non-Hits - Lindsey

[tilthefirefades]

Murrow is one of my very favorite songs of all time, to me it is the ultimate "jam". When I really want to test a new sound system or I just want to rock out in general, it is the song I go to. Love it beyond belief.

[Fireflies]

red rover.

[CADreaming]

Originally Posted by elle

but the dance songs are not in competition.

i will never get this rule that everybody here seems to like... why not choose the song instead of choosing a specific version?

These polls have been album specific. But, that would be a great idea for a poll -- pitting versions against each other.

I agree that it was weird to put BTLH on SYW and it's why I didn't choose BTLH in this poll. I like both versions, but The Dance would probably win out.

I chose WTWCT and SYHA.

[TrueFaith77]

SYHA and BTLH are peak modern Lindsey and also, not coincidentally, the most classic-sounding tracks of his tracks on the album. However, I am more than happy to see Red Rover in the top 2. Tough choice between those 3 for me.


Oh I see Say Goodbye has snuck in there. Surprising. Beautiful song though, but I prefer the live version.

[MacShadowsBall]

Originally Posted by jbrownsjr

whoops I took 3. Didn't realize I had.

No problem.

Originally Posted by elle

but the dance songs are not in competition.

i will never get this rule that everybody here seems to like... why not choose the song instead of choosing a specific version?

mainly because there can sooo many versions of the songs - numerous demo, live, and single/alternate edited versions, that everybody being on the same page judging the same version is the most accurate and least confusing.

Originally Posted by CADreaming

These polls have been album specific. But, that would be a great idea for a poll -- pitting versions against each other.

Thanks, CADreaming...One of my options back in Feb was a "favorite live performance" contest which would have put all the live versions of a song fighting in out in a poll. Of course something like that could be expanded to include not just those live versions, but other versions as well.

[Ashley]

I voted for Come and Bleed to Love Her. I've always enjoyed those songs, especially live.

[Dodfather]

Miranda and Steal Your Heart Away. I love Miranda, especially how it's featured in the Destiny Rules documentary.

[Lindsfan]

Originally Posted by elle

oh this is impossible to choose, he has way too many great songs on SYW... (and a few crappy ones like What's The World Coming To, and Aznavour-sounding singing parts of Say Goodbye).

Agreed, except I also like WTWCT which is NOT crappy

Murrow, Come, Steal Your Heart Away and Miranda are all favorites of mine. I love this album ( Say Goodbye, I can do without - except live. ) but, as much as I love those 4 songs, it's a no-brainer for me to choose the top two: #1 - Red Rover and #2 - Bleed To Love Her

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by Lindsfan

Agreed, except I also like WTWCT which is NOT crappy

Murro

I agree. WTWCT is one of my favorites on SYW!

[MacShadowsBall]

Steal Your Heart Away wins with 24 votes, and will move on to the SYW finals.