Thread: Crush
View Single Post
  #48  
Old 04-18-2005, 11:50 AM
GateandGarden GateandGarden is offline
Addicted Ledgie
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 6,560
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by SteveMacD
Amber and Gateandgarden, get real. This whole thread started when somebody's college professor said he had a crush on Christine. The poster even clarified that the professor did in fact mean Christine, not Stevie, which was a surprise to said poster. So, essentially, this is a thread about why some guys have a crush on Christine and not Stevie. And, Homer, being a GUY, is simply expressing why he has a crush on Christine and not Stevie.

Sorry to burst your chiffon bubble, but Stevie is NOT normal. Normal women don't go around in public always wearing chiffon and platforms (or Reeboks with rhinestones glued to them ). Normal women don't have a huge entourage. Normal women wear jeans and sneakers, or slacks and blazers, or dresses. In other words, most women are like Christine, not Stevie. But who cares? Do you think Stevie WANTS to be normal? No, she wants to be a star. She wants to be a recognizable celebrity, and the only way to be THAT is to be different. I mean, Mick is different and is easily recognized while John is normal and could easily get lost in a crowd.

Yes, dream catchers are part of certain people's religions, but not Stevie's. She's gone on record as being a born-again Christian. But, that's not why most people think of her as a fragil, fairy princess type. Stevie has her schtick. She's become this caricature that she created YEARS ago, and a lot of people don't buy it. A lot of people also have issues with her twirling and her song topics, which feed into the caricature (and, please note, I'm not saying I don't like the songs listed, because I like most of them):
Rhiannon
Dreams
Gold Dust Woman
Sisters Of The Moon
Gypsy
Seven Wonders
Paper Doll
Sweet Girl
Illume (9/11)
Running Through The Garden
Bella Donna
Wild Heart
Gate And Garden
Enchanted
Nightbird
Sable On Blond
Beauty And The Beast
Ghosts
Alice
Juliet
Trouble In Shangri-La
Candlebright
Sorcerer
Planets Of The Universe
Bombay Sapphires

While Christine's songs are usually the safest on record, and can be dull, she sings normal, pop love songs. Nothing out of the ordinary. Pretty straight-forward. That's why people can relate to her more on a human level. You'll never see a Christine fan call her "the queen of rock" or refer to her as a "rock godess." Christine is just a normal woman who was asked to join her buddy's blues band, then fell into Fleetwood Mac, and then fell into rock stardom. Christine didn't ask for any of it. She's the antithesis of a rock star. She's one of us, and happened to get lucky. Stevie is almost like a diva. I think she's too nice a person and cares too much about her fans to be called a diva, but she does have that superstar quality about her. She is/was the superstar and the sex symbol of Fleetwood Mac. Christine was just the cute girl next door.

In any event, if you don't want to know why some guys prefer Christine over Stevie, then ignore a thread called "Crush" on the Christine board. You chiffon heads can be so insecure if somebody says they prefer ANYBODY over Stevie.
I'm not going to argue with everything here because I agree with some of what you've said. BUT, I don't see how you can call me or Amber "chiffonheads," considering we both criticize Stevie openly. Or maybe I don't understand exactly what a chiffonhead is. Maybe I don't have to be crazy to be a chiffonhead. Nevertheless, I don't really appreciate it being used in a derogatory way (sp?) to categorize me. About Stevie being normal, I agree that in comparison to the average person she is not normal, but she is normal for a superstar, in my opinion. She is also normal for a rich person. She owns some things that some of us consider unnecessary or even tacky, but don't most people with lots of money? You said that she's different, and she has to be in order to be famous. But does being different making someone abnormal? I don't think so.

I think you misread me when you say that I'm upset because someone prefers Christine over Stevie. I feel like you're not reading my posts very thoroughly. But, I will give you this--it is unfair of me to fault Homie for bringing Stevie into when Stevie was in it from the first post. I let that slip my mind--you're right.

About the song list...lots of people have creative bones in their bodies. Lots of people are even more "out there" (sorry that this is overused by me at this point) than Stevie is. What do those songs prove? That she's capable of using metaphors? Imagery? That makes her a writer. That doesn't really make her abnormal, IMO.

Oh yeah, and my name's Hillary. It's in my sig.
Reply With Quote