Well, if you are going to set the two songs up for comparison, use either two studio versions or two live versions. The links show Christine singing it live in 1984 with her solo band; and the other is a video homage to Eva Cassidy's great studio version.
IMO, both studio versions are equally great for different reasons. And Christine's 1984 performance of the tune is not one of her best. However, no matter how dazzling EC's remake is, I always feel a genuine emotional response when I hear Christine's studio version sung with honest humility. It's truly moving.
|