Favorite pre 75 album?
 

Mystery to me for me

Love Hypnotized & For your love ;):cool:

I love the Bob Welch era albums, but Mystery To Me is certainly special. It's sort of like the pre '75 Rumours- every single song is worth it's weight in gold.

That being said, I also adore the warty imperfection of Penguin, too.

Penguin, Mystery to Me and Heroes are Hard to Find. Great set of three albums...

Bare Trees closely followed by Mystery to Me.

ALL OF THEM!!!!

And, I MEAN, every damned one of them!!! :nod:

Mystery To Me! Forever, Hypnotized, and Why are my favorites.

Then Play On is obsolutely outstanding! :D

To be honest, I can´t even understand how anyone could think otherwise...
...but, then, when they lost Peter Green they became a different band, of course.

"Bare Trees" all the way!!!! :)

Has to be "Then Plan On"

Mystery to Me has always been my favorite with Heroes are hard to find a close second. After that Then Play On.

MTM is the one that SHOULD have catapulted them into the stratosphere!

Mystery to Me if I had to only pick just one. :D

The album that hooked me
 

Then Play On

It's got to be Then Play On. There are some utterly sublime, heartbreaking moments on that album. Even the Madges have grown on me over the years. But if I could build a time machine, the first thing that I would do after getting next week's lottery numbers would be to go back to 1969 and try and have a quiet word with Danny about When You Say.

After that, it's Mystery to Me, then the spacey ambiance of most of Future Games does it for me, Fleetwood Mac, Bare Trees, Penguin, Kiln House, Heroes, and then Mr Wonderful , which I hate to rank last because Peter's stuff is great.

I really have never understood the bad press that Penguin gets. Excise Roadrunner and it's fine.

Then Play On, the first album and Bare Trees. As for Penguin, I like Roadrunner :)