RE-DO of Tusk Song Survivor.
 

OK, Due to MASS confusion on my part, I have decided to re-do the game. So lets start fresh. :)

Welcome to Song Survivor, Tusk Style!!! OK Same basic rules apply. Immunity will be different, so please bear with me. OK so lets see the contestants......


Over & Over
The Ledge
Think About Me
Save Me A Place
Sara
What Makes You Think You'er The One
Storms
Thats All For Evreyone
Not That Funny
Sisters Of The Moon
Angel
That's Enough For Me
Brown Eyes
Never Make Me Cry
I Know I'm Not Wrong
Honey Hi
Beautiful Child
Walk A Thin Line
Tusk
Never Forget

HAPPY VOTING :)

---No Immunity Tonight for the simple fact it is the first round.

GO AWAY, SARA.

Well, looks like the other went down the ****ter :p


That's All For Everyone, again.


-Curt

"Not That Funny" needs to go, go, GO!

DrownD Sara, drownD

Round 1
 

That's All for Everyone.

I'm still trying to vote off "Walk a Thin Line."

Hillary

It's only fair "Honey Hi" goes first again, as it went before.

That's All For Everyone

That's All For Everyone

Out of twenty songs on the album, folks are voting off "Sara"... yet Carne was surprised that I was voting off "Save Me A Place."

Why isn't it a bigger surprise that people are voting off "Sara," of all songs?
Oh, nevermind... I know why. ;) :laugh:

Well, once again... I'm voting to boot "Save Me A Place."
Maybe at some point very soon, I'll get to vote for something else!

FLUSH THE SLUDGE..."Save Me A Place"

Save "Sara" from drownDing! :wavey:

Re-do Round 1
 

Re do??? Round 1
 

Uhm, again... "That's All For Everyone"; easily the weakest spot in here.

Transfer from the closed thread:
Ok, let's try to add something of an explanation for this for a change. ;)
I still think it's "veeeery, very good", don't get me wrong. But it is a weird mode for Stevie. You know the Tusk doc where she says that she set out to write something upbeat for a change because all of her songs are supposedly so serious. And still there is a certain darkness running through that I can't put my finger on.
My favourite bit is the end, that's when the guitar and the vocal start a little sparring match where they keep on spinning each other round and round. That's another classic Buckingham - Nicks dialogue. And I do think it worked very well live, you've probably heard the 11-6-1979 version with Stevie really going at it.
But yeah, I prefer the mushy stuff like the three Nicks ballads and the classic 'cock-rock (thanks David) of "Sisters Of The Moon" to it. "Angel", "Honey Hi" and "Save Me A Place" I would drop off first.

Round & Round #1.
 

So yes, "Honey Hi" again.

Ok can I say something. I really think the conversations and the fights should be kept to very small minimum. Not because I and I'm sure others don't like them. It has to do with how cluttered and messy the thread can get. I'm sure it'll be much much easier for Jake to count votes when he does have to pass by one of Johnny Stew's or Face of Glass's or Dissentions NOVELS. Seriously it's like you guys have never heard of the expression "short and sweet" :laugh: Just a suggestion.

Honey Hi once again!

Round 1
 

Honey Hi

Tynan

The most gag-inducing song of all time, which is, of course, Sara.

-Kate

Not That Funny... not that good either! Goodbye!

Not That Funny

A stratigic vote for Sara...

I can't believe all the "Honey Hi" hate! :shocked:

Round 1
 

Honey Hi. Then I'll get back to Save Me A Place.

Enlighten us, Johnny.

All right, if we're going to place strategic votes, then I must vote for

SARA. Outta here, baby.

And remember,

SAVE SAVE ME A PLACE!
And that goes for you, too, Gaius.

SAVE ME A PLACE must die.

SAVE SARA!!!

Not That Funny

And do you think that they would have drug Sara out for concert after all these years if they thought people were going to vote it off of Tusk Survivor?? In the words of Fred Willard from "A Mighty Wind": I don't think SO!

I am also going to vote to drop

Sara

Not That Funny!!! :eek:

I choose to vote off...
 

Sara. Totally strategic of course. :nod:

Sara What is this, the 8th vote? :thumbsup:

Shamus

Sara

DorwnD already.

Darling, I voted for it because I just plain don't like it on the album. Live, it's beautiful. On Tusk? I can't stand it and always skip it. For me, the song just goes nowhere, whichever edit it is. Live is a different story because there's always something new or some little nuance that adds more flavor to it.

Ok, back to reality against Sara ostracism:

I have to vote off Honey Hi

Romy

that's all for everyone

That's All For Everyone

SAVE SARA!

that's all for everyone

SAVE SAVE ME A PLACE!
SAVE SARA!

I happen to love both of 'em :shrug: